Live data from Hacker News

EDE: Small and Fast Desktop Environment (2014)

edeproject.org

21–30 of 38 posts

Re: EDE: Small and Fast Desktop Environment (2014)

#21
post #8

I tried to search their wiki for wayland, but got zero hits so I guess this is for X11 only? Edit: nevermind, I see this is relatively "ancient" software. Last release over 10 years ago :) Will take it for a spin on an old computer though

they posted literally just the wiki article for MUDs earlier, slow news day

Re: EDE: Small and Fast Desktop Environment (2014)

#22

Have we arrived at where everybody knows what a desktop environment should look like? I mean, an end to experiments and variants and improvements. We all know how it should be and anything else is wrong. I would like that.

It depends... I've found things I like and dislike with every DE I've ever touched... from early windows, to OS/2, Mac old and new, Amiga, BeOS, and even some bits from more modern Windows. On my personal desktop, I've been running Cosmic, as it's close to what I want. I had run Budgie desktop previously and had it tweaked very specific to my liking, but it was a hodge-podge and I just wanted an out of the box experience easier to deal with.

I think there is/was a lot to like with the Win9x interface that I feel advanced a lot through to Windows 7 even. I think the current taskbar in windows is relatively nice too, but the start menu itself has taken a few steps back. I'd like to see Cosmic get a bit closer to the taskbar, but keeping it's application menus and settings, which get better with each iteration imo. There's still something alien about the spacing on the dock's corners though.

Re: EDE: Small and Fast Desktop Environment (2014)

#23

Have we arrived at where everybody knows what a desktop environment should look like? I mean, an end to experiments and variants and improvements. We all know how it should be and anything else is wrong. I would like that.

No?

Be forced to use Gnome because some royal 'We' decided that's what a DM should be? No farking way. Force someone else to use KDE because I think Gnome is kinda awful? No. Give up on low-resource desktop environments because Gnome or what ever is The One True DE? Sorry...no.

I would not like that.

Re: EDE: Small and Fast Desktop Environment (2014)

#25
Oh nice. I occasionally mention EDE in desktop roundups on El Reg. Glad it is not forgotten.

It's based on FLTK, and although the effort to create FLTK 2.0 faltered and died a few years ago, last year there was a new point release, FLTK 1.4, the first in 13 years.

I wrote about it almost exactly a year ago:

https://www.theregister.com/2024/11/26/fltk_14_released/

(In researching that I discovered that apparently it's not pronounced "eff ell tee kay" but "full tick".)

Since then it's got up to 1.4.4, and they're working on FLTK 1.5. And yes it supports Wayland now.

So maybe it's time for a new release of EDE to go with it. :-)

https://www.fltk.org/

Re: EDE: Small and Fast Desktop Environment (2014)

#27

Earlier quoted context omitted.

theres a windows 9x total conversion out there iirc

Chicago95 theme for XFCE is great

Looks more legit than Redmond97.

If we go retro then I would go for a MacOS 9 look. Like what this user achieved: https://www.reddit.com/r/unixporn/comments/tsric2/xfce_color...

Re: EDE: Small and Fast Desktop Environment (2014)

#30
post #19

I like the look of this. It looks like mate, which I presently use. I wonder what the difference is

Well, FLTK instead of GTK is a big one. Also, EDE more closely mimics the Win98 Explorer rather than GNOME. EDE is also lighter weight.

But it's the same desktop, menus, windows, icons thing with nothing fancy tacked on pretty much. Right?
Post reply on HN