Live data from Hacker News

Alchemy

joshcollinsworth.com

21–24 of 24 posts

Re: Alchemy

#21
post #12

Why do people want to present some tired point, that has already been made a thousand times, like some clever new insight? At least, if you believe that, engage with some counter-arguments at least, to make your article worth reading. This blog post is exactly the kind of slop (though not AI) that the author is criticizing.

I would argue that the author has no obligation to engage with more counter-arguments, or provide something "new" (to you) to the conversation. This is a blog. Blog posts are a way to show the voice of the author, share their thoughts on the matter, perhaps work through their own thought processes and come to a nice conclusion for themselves that they choose to share with the public. I would find the internet and the…

do you think machine mass-printed books are less valuable to read than hand written ones?

Re: Alchemy

#22
post #12

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I would argue that the author has no obligation to engage with more counter-arguments, or provide something "new" (to you) to the conversation. This is a blog. Blog posts are a way to show the voice of the author, share their thoughts on the matter, perhaps work through their own thought processes and come to a nice conclusion for themselves that they choose to share with the public. I would find the internet and the…

do you think machine mass-printed books are less valuable to read than hand written ones?

Fascinating phrasing. I am engaging you precisely, because I am uncertain what you meant, but am curious.

Do you mean value as perceived by the reader? Do you mean value as 'price' of book?

Re: Alchemy

#23

There was a real world example akin to the alchemists getting their wish of making gold and finding out that that destroyed the value of it -- Spanish colonialism. Spain brought back tons of silver and gold from the New World and instead of making them wealthy it crashed their economy by hyperinflation. https://www.worldhistory.org/article/2045/the-gold-of-the-co...

And cochineal red dye, which outvalued the gold they brought back. But that doesn't negate any point your making; it's simply another constituent.

I wonder if there was a surge in red clothing immediately after... perhaps followed by the wealthy disdaining it.

Re: Alchemy

#24

Earlier quoted context omitted.

do you think machine mass-printed books are less valuable to read than hand written ones?

Fascinating phrasing. I am engaging you precisely, because I am uncertain what you meant, but am curious. Do you mean value as perceived by the reader? Do you mean value as 'price' of book?

non-native speaker.

meant reader perceived value, obviously a hand written book will cost more dollars.

Post reply on HN