Live data from Hacker News

SanDisk launches dongle-like Extreme Fit USB-C flash drive with up to 1 TB

notebookcheck.net

21–30 of 158 posts

Re: SanDisk launches dongle-like Extreme Fit USB-C flash drive with up to 1 TB

#21

How hot do these things get? I have a few "bar" type USB sticks that get quite warm after even moderate amounts of data transfer.

With how short the drive is, I think the USB port and the rest of your pc’s motherboard will act as a heatsink for the drive.

Re: SanDisk launches dongle-like Extreme Fit USB-C flash drive with up to 1 TB

#22
post #16

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I have two SSK USB sticks that give me write speeds of up to 1GB/s (as long as they're not filled to the brim). I've copied things like 80GB games in something like 2-3 minutes. A real SSD will always be best, but I'm pretty happy with these USB sticks.

The USB sticks you talk about are basically USB SSDs, not what we know as traditional thumb drives. I have a similar one too from HP(PNY), and it's crazy fast for its size, but the issue is its controller (ASMedia IIRC) reports it to the OS as a UAS (USB Attached SCSI), similar to an external HDD, instead of Removable Mass Storage as most thumb drives do, so you can't hot -plug/-unplug it, and that controller seems t…

This USB SSD boots Debian Linux 6.1 kernel on HP Ryzen laptop, https://www.pny.com/PNY-DUO-Link-V3-USB-3-2-Gen-2-Type-C-OTG...

Re: SanDisk launches dongle-like Extreme Fit USB-C flash drive with up to 1 TB

#23
post #11

I've pretty much stopped using 'stick' type storage for anything >256MB, as regardless of brand and series, my experience is that these thingies overheat under anything but light write usage, and either slow to a crawl or drop off the USB bus entirely before my copy is finished. 'Credit card' sized SSDs are not that much more inconvenient to carry and store, and don't exhibit any of these issues for me. And the therm…

Even smaller and faster are nvme enclosures over thunderbolt. Easily can be boot drive.

Any recommended enclosures that work reliably with Linux?

Re: SanDisk launches dongle-like Extreme Fit USB-C flash drive with up to 1 TB

#24

I've pretty much stopped using 'stick' type storage for anything >256MB, as regardless of brand and series, my experience is that these thingies overheat under anything but light write usage, and either slow to a crawl or drop off the USB bus entirely before my copy is finished. 'Credit card' sized SSDs are not that much more inconvenient to carry and store, and don't exhibit any of these issues for me. And the therm…

NVMe enclosure are cheap, mine is a ugreen supporting usb 3.2 gen2 and i paid less than 20 euro. Put any kind of half decent nvme in it covered by one of those cheap heat dissipator.

Re: SanDisk launches dongle-like Extreme Fit USB-C flash drive with up to 1 TB

#27
Back when Macbook airs had tiny drives and sdcard slots, there were multiple vendors selling flush-mount sd cards. They work surprisingly well, they can sink heat well into the aluminum body.

This product isn't quite there yet, but it's clearly aiming for the same market.

Re: SanDisk launches dongle-like Extreme Fit USB-C flash drive with up to 1 TB

#28
post #11

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Even smaller and faster are nvme enclosures over thunderbolt. Easily can be boot drive.

Any recommended enclosures that work reliably with Linux?

These days most of them seem to work just fine on Linux, Windows, and Mac. I use several brands across all 3 and never had an issue. I like the DOCKCASE Visual Smart ($40) or Explorer Edition ($50). They have large capacitors to provide 10 seconds of power loss protection, support 10Gbps USB speeds, and have a second USB port just for power which makes it compatible with SSD's that draw a lot of power. I like the info on the little screens because I swap SSD's in/out frequently. There are cheaper ones that work fine too - the "SABRENT USB 3.2 Type-C Tool-Free Enclosure" ($30) is nice for, well, not needing a screwdriver to swap out the drive - but it might not deliver enough power for some overkill SSD like the (now Sandisk) WD Black SN8100 - but the DockCase will, as long as you also plug in an auxiliary power USB cable.

A drive like the Patriot Memory P400 Lite is very low power, so it works with cheaper enclosures or USB ports that don't deliver as much power to the peripheral. It also generates less heat, which can help sustain performance depending on the enclosure and environment.

Re: SanDisk launches dongle-like Extreme Fit USB-C flash drive with up to 1 TB

#29

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The USB sticks you talk about are basically USB SSDs, not what we know as traditional thumb drives. I have a similar one too from HP(PNY), and it's crazy fast for its size, but the issue is its controller (ASMedia IIRC) reports it to the OS as a UAS (USB Attached SCSI), similar to an external HDD, instead of Removable Mass Storage as most thumb drives do, so you can't hot -plug/-unplug it, and that controller seems t…

This USB SSD boots Debian Linux 6.1 kernel on HP Ryzen laptop, https://www.pny.com/PNY-DUO-Link-V3-USB-3-2-Gen-2-Type-C-OTG...

Thanks I already switched to a SATA SSD with USB3.0 adapter that works for booting Linux, I'm just annoyed spending the money on a fast pricy USB drive that doesn't work for anything else than Windows file transfers because of some BS technicality.

Re: SanDisk launches dongle-like Extreme Fit USB-C flash drive with up to 1 TB

#30

Back when Macbook airs had tiny drives and sdcard slots, there were multiple vendors selling flush-mount sd cards. They work surprisingly well, they can sink heat well into the aluminum body. This product isn't quite there yet, but it's clearly aiming for the same market.

I have a few of those still lying around, they were great!
Post reply on HN