Live data from Hacker News

Bitcoin Foundation Launches to ‘Standardize, Protect and Promote’ Bitcoin

betabeat.com

21–29 of 29 posts

Re: Bitcoin Foundation Launches to ‘Standardize, Protect and Promote’ Bitcoin

#21
post #7
post #6

I think an encrypted currency base managed only by computers and the market is fairer than a system run by a few men. Also I like privacy.

I think it could be fairer or it could be a way to get stuck with a broken monetary policy forever.

The only monetary policy that isn't broken, is one that doesn't exist.

Re: Bitcoin Foundation Launches to ‘Standardize, Protect and Promote’ Bitcoin

#22
post #21
post #7

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I think it could be fairer or it could be a way to get stuck with a broken monetary policy forever.

The only monetary policy that isn't broken, is one that doesn't exist.

I don't think that's possible. Even keeping the number of BTC fixed is a policy.

Re: Bitcoin Foundation Launches to ‘Standardize, Protect and Promote’ Bitcoin

#23
post #19

Ah, the long-storied September announcement. Pretty good idea overall. I'd be happiest seeing a set of security best-practices agreed upon and some sort of mechanism for organizations and businesses to elect for auditing.

Totally agreed; this and paying Gavin were my two main motivations upfront.

I really desire bitcointalk'ers to have some objective way to assess business quality when they consider how many percent per week return is a reasonable no-risk promise.

Re: Bitcoin Foundation Launches to ‘Standardize, Protect and Promote’ Bitcoin

#24
post #15

Earlier quoted context omitted.

In a very literal sense it can be forked: https://github.com/bitcoin/bitcoin You wouldn't need to try and duplicate an ecosystem. People with nodes on the network would "vote with their CPU power" to support the version they liked the best - so the best one would naturally get the most support.

the best one would naturally get the most support I don't think so. A "better" Bitcoin fork that has no MtGox, no BitInstant, no BitPay, no blockexplorer, etc. would probably have very low adoption.

agree and disagree. if a fork is demonstrably, significantly better, then adoption will grow and eventually, in general, the better will win. this is how evolution works.

Re: Bitcoin Foundation Launches to ‘Standardize, Protect and Promote’ Bitcoin

#25

A while ago I wrote that perhaps the greatest contribution the Bitcoin experiment will make to humankind is to teach you and me and our neighbors more about the realities of economics. And now I will add that the Bitcoin experiment will also contribute to greater understanding of how nonprofit industry associations are organized to protect the economic interests of for-profit businesses. A lot of new industries have…

"A lot of new industries have discovered that a few bad actors who screw up early can damage the reputation of the entire industry"

Please cite some examples. I can't come up with any, and this is intuitively false to me. Productive industries steamroll over bad actors and indiscretion. Railroads, gold-mining, and arguably social gaming were propelled by bad actors.

Re: Bitcoin Foundation Launches to ‘Standardize, Protect and Promote’ Bitcoin

#26
post #17
post #10

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I am not sure that is true. As small as the ecosystem is, I would not want to try to duplicate it.

There are plenty of forks running already. There's "litecoin", a fork that changes the proof of work algorithm to scrypt in an attempt to make GPU's less useful for mining. There's "PPCoin", a fork that adds "Proof of Stake" alongside "Proof of Work" in an attempt to reduce the energy consumption of the mining process. There's others as well. Some bitcoin proponents consider these "scam" coins as they have limited us…

Don't forget Namecoin, repurposing the Bitcoin block chain for storing DNS records!

Re: Bitcoin Foundation Launches to ‘Standardize, Protect and Promote’ Bitcoin

#28
post #27

Here's their website: https://www.bitcoinfoundation.org/

Looks down from here :( (and here: http://www.isup.me/www.bitcoinfoundation.org )

So it is. They also have the domain http://www.bitcoinfoundation.com/ - but no luck.

Re: Bitcoin Foundation Launches to ‘Standardize, Protect and Promote’ Bitcoin

#29
post #22
post #21

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The only monetary policy that isn't broken, is one that doesn't exist.

I don't think that's possible. Even keeping the number of BTC fixed is a policy.

True, but participation in bitcoin is voluntary, whereas participation in governmental monetary policy is not :)
Post reply on HN