Live data from Hacker News

Retrocide Mono – A monospaced font with no decenders

geonot.github.io

21–30 of 63 posts

Re: Retrocide Mono – A monospaced font with no decenders

#21

The squished descenders are surprisingly not horrible. (They are horrible in some actual 80s fonts from 8-bit devices.) But I don't like the giant intrusive 'l' that looks like a ladle, it's got too much character.

Looks cool, I feel like lowercase g and maybe p could be a bit taller, g looks a bit out of place with its height.

Re: Retrocide Mono – A monospaced font with no decenders

#22

Hey, this is my first font design, constructive criticism welcome! Thanks.

Please add a github release with the assets (ttf, otf, etc.). I'm developing an open-source font repository+downloader and it will make it easier to write an install script for it.

Re: Retrocide Mono – A monospaced font with no decenders

#23

The squished descenders are surprisingly not horrible. (They are horrible in some actual 80s fonts from 8-bit devices.) But I don't like the giant intrusive 'l' that looks like a ladle, it's got too much character.

zx spectrum is very offended by your remarks, and would like to have a word with you :-) I can see that g with my eyes closed.

Ha, that's the one, I knew there was one particularly egregious g.

Re: Retrocide Mono – A monospaced font with no decenders

#24

I'm unsure if "no descenders" provides increased clarity. For example, lowercase q is easy to recognize because your eyes are already drawn to it being one of few characters that descend. In the case of this font, you have a small uppercase Q as the lowercase q. This feels like it accomplishes the opposite of this stated benefit.

Nowhere does it promise to increase clarity. In one place it says "modern clarity", which is in my opinion and many cases worse than non-modern clarity.

Re: Retrocide Mono – A monospaced font with no decenders

#28

I'm unsure if "no descenders" provides increased clarity. For example, lowercase q is easy to recognize because your eyes are already drawn to it being one of few characters that descend. In the case of this font, you have a small uppercase Q as the lowercase q. This feels like it accomplishes the opposite of this stated benefit.

Nowhere does it promise to increase clarity. In one place it says "modern clarity", which is in my opinion and many cases worse than non-modern clarity.

Modern claritu

Re: Retrocide Mono – A monospaced font with no decenders

#29

Hey, this is my first font design, constructive criticism welcome! Thanks.

You’ve picked a difficult way to make your first typeface. A monoline design with a strict vector grid doesn’t leave a lot of room for the kind of optical adjustments needed for balanced and readable letter shapes. But I think even if you want to be strict about those restrictions there is a lot of room for improvement in consistency and composition of each shape.

I started to write actionable suggestions about individual letters but realized it’s probably better to drop this link, which starts at how to draw an ”A” and continues with every letter of the alphabet. https://ohnotype.co/blog/ohno-type-school-a

Post reply on HN