Live data from Hacker News

Gentoo Linux might be the best desktop Linux distro for advanced Linux users

news.ycombinator.com

21–30 of 67 posts

Re: Gentoo Linux might be the best desktop Linux distro for advanced Linux users

#21
Gentoo will always have a special place in my heart.

It's always been my goto if I want absolute maximum rice or feeling of control.

The Gentoo handbook is also amazing, especially the pages going over the nitty gritty details.

Personally though I'm more interested in nixos (if I want to roll my own) these days for it's immutable features.

Re: Gentoo Linux might be the best desktop Linux distro for advanced Linux users

#23
post #2

Gentoo is great if you value your time at $0.

Gentoo Linux became a lot easier with binary packages and binary linux kernel. You don't need to customize it, but you can still get packages from third party overlays. The customizability is available when you need it or want it. Learning to use gentoo's basic functionality doesn't cost a lot of time, and I recommend utilizing only the basic functionality in most cases. Just stick to the basics, and you will be fine…

Unfortunately the binary packages are still only available upto x86-64-v3, so users on x86-64-v4 (which I reckon what majority of "advanced" users would be using) and even more so AMD Zen 4/5 users would be missing out on advanced instructions and other compile optimisations.

Luckily Arch/CachyOS users don't have to worry about this as CachyOS offers optimised packages for modern CPUs. Until Gentoo offers an equivalent - without manual compiling needed - I won't consider it.

Re: Gentoo Linux might be the best desktop Linux distro for advanced Linux users

#24
Running gentoo on desktop, since 2007. My first installation lasted 7 years. The next one has worked well for me since 2013. It was my first real contact with linux and taught me a lot. My setup is bargain bin components from the same 2013 but I update and compile world during the nights.

I'm thinking of finally upgrading my components as Sandy Bridge is not cutting it in all tasks any more. Told my Gentoo-loving friend that I wouldn't be installing Gentoo again. That's only because I'm planning on just using this current installation with fresh recompilations!

Re: Gentoo Linux might be the best desktop Linux distro for advanced Linux users

#25
post #17

With malware reportedly uploaded by random people to AUR, I will stick to Debian. A good thing about proprietary OS is that, they are responsible if their repos are infected. Are packages carefully reviewed by gentoo?

PPAs are your AUR

Re: Gentoo Linux might be the best desktop Linux distro for advanced Linux users

#26
Could you maybe elaborate on your statement that...

> Gentoo overlays are better designed than debian/ubuntu PPA(personal package archive)s and AUR(arch user repository).

...because from what the Gentoo wiki states, an overlay is a repository of packages from which Portage will automatically install packages. That is a clear contrast to the AUR from which you manually get a package so you have the chance to inspect it without Pacman automatically going and installing it. For Arch a closer equivalent would be unofficial user repositories.

Re: Gentoo Linux might be the best desktop Linux distro for advanced Linux users

#28
post #17

With malware reportedly uploaded by random people to AUR, I will stick to Debian. A good thing about proprietary OS is that, they are responsible if their repos are infected. Are packages carefully reviewed by gentoo?

PPAs are your AUR

Are you confusing Debian and Ubuntu?

Re: Gentoo Linux might be the best desktop Linux distro for advanced Linux users

#29
I used gentoo for years. While I still have a fond spot for those memories, saying that it is simpler than nixos is just flat out wrong. I've vastly simplified my involvement and removed most pitfalls from my day to day. Years pass with minimal breakage or churn and my devices just keep working.

Re: Gentoo Linux might be the best desktop Linux distro for advanced Linux users

#30
post #28

Earlier quoted context omitted.

PPAs are your AUR

Are you confusing Debian and Ubuntu?

> Are you confusing Debian and Ubuntu?

No, you're confusing exclusivity. https://launchpad.net/debian/+ppas

Post reply on HN