21–30 of 169 posts
>> const port = option("--port", integer());
I don't understand. Why is this a parser? Isn't it just way of enforcing a type in a language that doesn't have types?
I was expecting something like a state machine that takes the command line text and parses it to validate the syntax and values.
> Try to access it and TypeScript yells at you. No runtime validation needed. I was recently thinking about type safety and validation strategies are particularly thorny in languages where the typings are just annotations. E.g. the Typescript/Zod or Python/Pydantic universes. Especially in IO cases where the data doesn't originate in the same type system. In a language like Go (just an example, not endorsing) if you…
> worst case you're getting that struct with all the fields set to zero, and you just have to handle the zero values In the field I work, zero values are valid and doing it in Go would be a nightmare
I don't see anything in the post or the linked tutorial that gives a flavor of the user experience when you supply an invalid option. I tried running the example, but I've forgotten too much about Node and TypeScript to make it work. (It can't resolve the @optique references.) What happens when you pass --foo, --target bar, or --port 3.14?
> Think about it. When you get JSON from an API, you don't just parse it as any and then write a bunch of if-statements. You use something like Zod to parse it directly into the shape you want. Invalid data? The parser rejects it. Done. Isn’t writing code and using zod the same thing? The difference being who wrote the code. Of course, you hope zod is robust, tested, supported, extensible, and has docs so you can und…
> Of course, you hope zod is robust, tested, supported, extensible, and has docs so you can understand how to express your domain in terms it can help you with. And you hope you don’t have to spend too much time migrating as zod’s api changes.
Yes, judgement is required to make depending on zod (or any library) worthwhile. This is not different in principle from trusting those same things hold for TypeScript, or Node, or V8, or the C++ compiler V8 was compiled with, or the x86_64 chip it's running on, or the laws of physics.
The problem I run into here is - how do you create good error messages when you do this? If the user has passed you input with multiple problems, how do you build a list of everything that's wrong with it if the parser crashes out halfway through?