Live data from Hacker News

Why does AI feel so different?

blog.nilenso.com

21–30 of 105 posts

Re: Why does AI feel so different?

#21

The article keeps referring to "AI" as if it's a coherent, agreed-upon thing. It's not. "AI" is a marketing term that's been applied to whatever happens to look impressive at the moment---right now, that's LLMs. There's no settled definition, no unified discipline, and lumping everything from generative text models to actual robotics under the same label just obscures the discussion. If we're talking about LLMs, let'…

> There's zero evidence that LLMs have produced a measurable productivity boom

I’m not so sure on this one. AlphaFold2, while not quite an LLM, was based on Transformer architecture - and its implementation wasn’t a million miles away from a language model - and it massively improved the rate of protein structure prediction.

I think in general you’re correct, that we’re in a bubble, but I think it’s too extreme to say the technology is valueless.

Re: Why does AI feel so different?

#22

AI feels different because quietly we are all aware, to differing degrees of comfort, that the world around us is collapsing. We see the escalating effects of climate change impacting day-to-day life in ways we were told would only happen in the far future, witnessing genocide become a normal part of the news critique of which can mean serious personal consequences, we're watching the United States transform into Sta…

China manages to have long term planning. The only planning Trump and co do is planning how to line their own pockets.

Re: Why does AI feel so different?

#24

Replacing our thinking with a few monopolistic tech companies... What could go wrong!

Not just our thinking, but our search for truth. The biggest problem I see is that models can hallucinate or be biased (for example, Grok being told explicitly not to mention Trump and Musk when asked about misinformation) for the benefit of their owners or creators. This happens with Chinese models too, of course, because of their laws.

The problem is that people just trust what the LLM tells them, not realising they can be misled, or the model tells them "you're right" without any pushback or invitation to think further—just like an echo chamber, the consequences of which we've seen with social media in the last few years

Re: Why does AI feel so different?

#25
I recently saw a good example of how LLM's can be really useful.

A friend of mine, who always found learning difficult, now works as a plumber and installer with his own one-person company.

One of his clients is the local community pool. He took over the job from an older man who showed him how everything worked. My friend noticed a lot of inefficient (manual) use of energy and resources, but the previous installer told him it would cost too much to automate, so nothing was done.

The other day we talked about AI, and he said he had never tried it. I asked him to think of some questions from his daily work. He came up with questions about the pool system and how to automate it.

ChatGPT answered his questions correctly, and after a few follow-ups, it even provided a list of the parts he would need and a plan to make it work. Last weekend he told me that, together with the previous installer, he made improvements that should save the pool thousands of euros over the next few years.

Of course, an experienced pool expert might have come up with the same solution, but it is often difficult to convince a committee to hire someone when nothing is broken, the budget is already set, and the inefficiencies are not obvious.

My friend now uses ChatGPT several times a day to solve practical problems. It helps him learn new things and explore possibilities he might not have considered otherwise.

I do not mind if ChatGPT makes the occasional mistake or gives an answer based on outdated information. As long as it is used as a tool to improve your own abilities, the subscription is worth the cost.

When I worked with colleagues, I sometimes relied on advice that turned out to be wrong. Everyone makes mistakes, even when working to the best of their abilities, and I find that my AI 'colleagues' make fewer of them.

Re: Why does AI feel so different?

#26

It’s the first revolutionary technology that his first goal is to make money for VC investors instead of really change the world, the perceived benefit for society is just a sub-product of the ponzi scheme behind those VC firms.

The dot-com boom of the late 1990s also had plenty of VC money.

Back then and today, you find plenty of true believers, and plenty of people who are in it for the money.

Similar, when people financed eg canals and railways or factories in the past, many participants cared about the money.

(Or are you saying it's not about the money, but specifically VCs?)

Re: Why does AI feel so different?

#27

These are poor examples: > Why do I need to know what quarks are, or how steam engines work? Why do I need to know anything about anything? I can just look it up with AI Literally all possible with Google and YouTube.

And a bit earlier with books and libraries.

Over time, we reduced friction and cost.

Re: Why does AI feel so different?

#28

"Ah cool a list of historic technologies that caused a paradigm shift... I wonder what second-order effects are to be expected from generative AI!" > Customer service automation, Agentic coding, Content creation Fucking hell. Customer service automation. Auto-spaghetti code. Brainrot as a service. Truly what society needs.

Agreed. Not what society needs, but what giant corporations and govs need for the society to well behave…

(Edit: typos)

Re: Why does AI feel so different?

#29

AI feels different because quietly we are all aware, to differing degrees of comfort, that the world around us is collapsing. We see the escalating effects of climate change impacting day-to-day life in ways we were told would only happen in the far future, witnessing genocide become a normal part of the news critique of which can mean serious personal consequences, we're watching the United States transform into Sta…

China manages to have long term planning. The only planning Trump and co do is planning how to line their own pockets.

China is a country. Lots of people live there. Some of them have long term planning for some aspects. Some of them don't.

Re: Why does AI feel so different?

#30

It’s the first revolutionary technology that his first goal is to make money for VC investors instead of really change the world, the perceived benefit for society is just a sub-product of the ponzi scheme behind those VC firms.

> It’s the first revolutionary technology that his first goal is to make money for VC investors instead of really change the world

Is that true?

Steam technology and factory machinery were created and used to make the pit, mill, and factory owners more money than with human workers. The railway mania in the 1840s was a period where vast sums of money were invested in railway lines and engine technology.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Railway_Mania

Post reply on HN