Live data from Hacker News

Constitution of the United States Website has removed sections

reddit.com

21–30 of 176 posts

Re: Constitution of the United States Website has removed sections

#21

When do specific actions taken by the current US administration cross the legal line into treason or other legal lines where defense against domestic enemies is warranted?

probably nothing that relates to information on a consumer website. even bringing up treason in this context is so wildly alarmist that it detracts from your credibility.

Re: Constitution of the United States Website has removed sections

#23

When do specific actions taken by the current US administration cross the legal line into treason or other legal lines where defense against domestic enemies is warranted?

Didn't the Supreme Court declare anything the administration does, legal..? Or was that just for the president?

Re: Constitution of the United States Website has removed sections

#25

This is not normal.

True, but I’m glad they are making it public. The old US is gone; time to figure out where we go from here.

Sounds like maybe a positive spin on the erosion of the fundamental building blocks of our democracy. This to me is a strange take, if I’m reading that correctly, what do you mean by it?

Re: Constitution of the United States Website has removed sections

#26

When do specific actions taken by the current US administration cross the legal line into treason or other legal lines where defense against domestic enemies is warranted?

well you see, the congress and supreme court have decided that no, actually, this is what they want to happen.

Re: Constitution of the United States Website has removed sections

#27
post #24
post #16

I would have to imagine this is an accident or rogue vandalism -- I don't think USGOV is trying to stealth-edit the constitution by truncating the last 18 paragraphs of Article I.

you should check what the removed sections contain.

I could see an intern or staffer trying to protest violations of habeus corpus by doing this, I guess. gets more eyes on it

Re: Constitution of the United States Website has removed sections

#29

Good use case for a git diff. The removed bits discuss habeaus corpus, emoluments, and congressional oversight of the military.

I wanted to do the Constitution (and US law in general) in git, but dates before unix epoch weren't possible. I don't think it's since been fixed. I had went so far as to start digging up treaties (about 700 of them, ratified) and draft constitutions (would have been non-master branches of some sort). It would be nice if Congress and legislatures actually used git as a matter of law, having names attached to every co…

I don't really think Git is the appropriate tool for version control on legislation. There's hundreds of thousands of actions/conversations/motions on each "commit" to a nation's legislation, and all of those actions need to be tracked permanently. Moreover, most countries have an "append-only" approach to legislation, where the original document doesn't get removed, but overridden by the new.

Look at the UK's Hansard[0] as an example. Every word spoken in Parliament leading up to legislation being introduced is tracked and published. Those conversations eventually turn into Bills on the Parliament site[1], and eventually those bills turn into legislation[2]. These websites are all digital versions of the old paper copies which go back centuries.

[0] - https://hansard.parliament.uk

[1] - https://bills.parliament.uk

[2] - https://www.legislation.gov.uk

Re: Constitution of the United States Website has removed sections

#30

When do specific actions taken by the current US administration cross the legal line into treason or other legal lines where defense against domestic enemies is warranted?

We are waaayyy passed that line. We are, for just about every definition, living in an authoritarian state. Trump has immunity, from the Supreme Court, support in the house and senate, support of the media, and enough support from the military. Freaadom isnt free. I think americans forget that. They are waiting for someone else to come save them, which will NEVER happen.

[flagged]
Post reply on HN