Live data from Hacker News

It's rude to show AI output to people

distantprovince.by

21–30 of 257 posts

Re: It's rude to show AI output to people

#21
I have one of those coworkers. I tell him I have a problem with a missing BIOS setting. He comes back 2 minutes later "Yeah I asked an LLM and it said to go into [submenu that doesn't exist] and uncheck [setting I'm trying to find].

What's even more infuriating is that he won't take "I've checked and that submenu doesn't exist" for an answer and insists to check again. Had to step away for a fag a few times in fear of putting his face through the desk.

Re: It's rude to show AI output to people

#23

It's deeply sad to me that I will never again be able to read a message from someone and know, for sure, that it was written by them themselves.

We will have a web where proof of humanity is the de facto standard. Its only a question of when. Things have to get worse before they get better in afraid

Re: It's rude to show AI output to people

#24
post #7

This is an interesting take. Cause all an LLM is, is a reflection of its input. Garbage in garbage out. If we're going to have this rule about AI, maybe we should have it about... everything. From your mom's last Facebook post, to what is said by influencers to this post... Say less. Do more.

An LLM's output being a reflection of its output would imply determinism, which is the opposite of their value prop. "Garbage in, garbage out" is an addage born from traditional data pipelines. "Anything in, generic slop, possibly garbage, out" is the new status quo.

Re: It's rude to show AI output to people

#25
post #4

I really wish some of my coworkers would stop using LLMs to write me emails or even Teams messages. It does feel extremely rude, to the point I don't even want to read them anymore.

https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&que...

Wow. What a good giveaway.

I wonder what others there are.

I occasionally use bullet points, emdashes (unicode, single, and double hyphens) and words like "delve". I hate it think these are the new heuristics.

I think AI is a useful tool (especially image and video models), but I've already had folks (on HN [1]!) call out my fully artisanal comments as LLM-generated. It's almost as annoying as getting low-effort LLM splurge from others.

Edit: As it turns out, cow-orkers isn't actually an LLMism. It's both a joke and a dictation software mistake. Oops.

[1] most recently https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44482876

Re: It's rude to show AI output to people

#26
Yes it is absolutely rude in many contexts. In a team context you are looking for common understanding and being “on the same page”. If someone needs to consult AI to get up to speed that’s fine, then their interaction with you should reflect what they have learned.

Re: It's rude to show AI output to people

#27
post #7

This is an interesting take. Cause all an LLM is, is a reflection of its input. Garbage in garbage out. If we're going to have this rule about AI, maybe we should have it about... everything. From your mom's last Facebook post, to what is said by influencers to this post... Say less. Do more.

That's not really true at all, at least at the end user level.

You can have a very thoughtful LLM prompt and get a garbage response if the model fails to generate a solid, sound answer to your prompt. Hard questions with verifiable but obscure answers, for instance, where it generates fake citations.

You can have a garbage prompt and get not-garbage output if you are asking in a well-understood area with a well-understood problem.

And the current generation of company-provided LLMs are VERY highly trained to make the answer look non-garbage in all cases, increasing the cognitive load on you to figure out.

Re: It's rude to show AI output to people

#29
I couldn't disagree more. Its like someone going to Wikipedia to helpfully copy and paste a summary of an issue. Fast and with a good enough level of accuracy.

Generally the AI summaries I see are more topical and accurate than the many other comments in the thread.

Post reply on HN