Live data from Hacker News

Google Ordered to Pay $315M for Taking Data from Idle Android Phones

reuters.com

21–22 of 22 posts

Re: Google Ordered to Pay $315M for Taking Data from Idle Android Phones

#21

Analysts are now thinking in EBITDAS: Earnings Before Interest, Taxes, Depreciation, Amortization, and Slaps on the Wrist.

How much does this particular slap reduce earnings really? Alphabet shows $41 billion before tax, so 0.7%? Assuming they do pay that amount. I'm not well-versed in financial matters so please check my numbers.

http://abc.xyz/investor/

Re: Google Ordered to Pay $315M for Taking Data from Idle Android Phones

#22
post #15

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I did suspect Poe was involved. Been trying to think it through, but I guess I'm getting annoyed by how trivial people seem to think fines are. I'm not sure how to research this, but it seems like most companies hit with a fine like that will change their behavior. Malicious compliance exists (and I would not put it past Google), but it is at least moving in a better direction. That said. I also think Google has acce…

Google just got hit with a $314 million fine for secretly tracking Android users’ locations. Sounds big, right? Not really. In 2024, Alphabet made $62 billion in net income — this fine is just 0.5% of that. History shows fines this small don’t change corporate behavior. Take HSBC. In 2012, they paid $1.9 billion for laundering cartel and sanctioned-country money — 11% of their profit that year. Still, they were later…

> Google just got hit with a $314 million fine for secretly tracking Android users’ locations

It didn't. It got sued for using users' metered cellular data and received a judgment telling it to pay users for that data usage. There is nothing about a fine for secretly tracking locations here.

Post reply on HN