Live data from Hacker News

BYOK – Bring Your Own Keyboard

byok.io

21–30 of 70 posts

Re: BYOK – Bring Your Own Keyboard

#21
If you’re charging $200 you should really be able to see more than 15 lines of text at a time.

I know the idea is to be distraction-free but it’s hard to justify over a basic writing app on the phone you already own, which includes a nicer screen.

Re: BYOK – Bring Your Own Keyboard

#22

Why is this so expensive? Raspberrypi zero 2w + some stripped down OS that boots directly to an editor, lcd display and a nice case would be much cheaper. Also easier to implement other stuff, like different fonts, use your own 'cloud' to sync stuff (and not being forced into a subscription), etc.

Because a bag of parts isn’t a functioning device, and things like labor and customer support cost money? Things like a “nice case” can only be done affordably when you’re stamping out tens of thousands of the things.

Re: BYOK – Bring Your Own Keyboard

#24
The question is how gimped the device is going to be if you don't want to lease their software monthly?

There is a special place in hell for people who make hardware that runs static software, but still withhold ownership just so they can indefinitely bilk money from you.

Re: BYOK – Bring Your Own Keyboard

#25

If you’re charging $200 you should really be able to see more than 15 lines of text at a time. I know the idea is to be distraction-free but it’s hard to justify over a basic writing app on the phone you already own, which includes a nicer screen.

Yea for me having lots of vertical real estate is important while writing. iPad Mini (or Daylight Computer if you care about working outdoors) in portrait orientation combined with any number of writing apps seems like a great solution.

Re: BYOK – Bring Your Own Keyboard

#26
"Universal keyboard compatibility" -- bah!

I have working keyboards in my possession that this thing cannot connect to.

- No ADB port for a Mac keyboard

- No Sun Type 5 Mini-DIN

- No PS/2 port

- No PC keyboard port

- No Newton serial keyboard port

- No RJ11 for an LK-201

So much for universal.

Re: BYOK – Bring Your Own Keyboard

#27

If you’re charging $200 you should really be able to see more than 15 lines of text at a time. I know the idea is to be distraction-free but it’s hard to justify over a basic writing app on the phone you already own, which includes a nicer screen.

Where do you see 15 lines?

In the video they show the 3 text size modes. The smallest text size only shows 8 lines, even though the text on the screen claims it goes to 11: https://youtu.be/5hV8xfhdk7c?t=208 (3:28) I can't imagine 15 lines of text on a low resolution screen like that.

I like the concept of the device, but I must not be the target audience at all. I can't imagine spending time writing on a low-resolution, tiny LCD display like that for any extended period of time.

Even the response time of the LCD looks painfully slow in the video. The letters slowly fade into view as they're being typed. They only show the typing for a couple seconds so if you blink you'll miss it in the demo video. This is in contrast to the campaign's claims of zero latency and high responsiveness

Apparently there's a market for it, though, because they have a lot of Kickstarter backers.

Re: BYOK – Bring Your Own Keyboard

#28
post #26

"Universal keyboard compatibility" -- bah! I have working keyboards in my possession that this thing cannot connect to. - No ADB port for a Mac keyboard - No Sun Type 5 Mini-DIN - No PS/2 port - No PC keyboard port - No Newton serial keyboard port - No RJ11 for an LK-201 So much for universal.

I'd like to see that collection of keyboards

Do you have any interesting layout and language variations?

Re: BYOK – Bring Your Own Keyboard

#30

Why is this so expensive? Raspberrypi zero 2w + some stripped down OS that boots directly to an editor, lcd display and a nice case would be much cheaper. Also easier to implement other stuff, like different fonts, use your own 'cloud' to sync stuff (and not being forced into a subscription), etc.

Wait until you find out the BOM for every device costs less than the retail price.
Post reply on HN