Live data from Hacker News

Nvidia CEO criticizes Anthropic boss over his statements on AI

tomshardware.com

21–30 of 195 posts

Re: Nvidia CEO criticizes Anthropic boss over his statements on AI

#21
The AI executives predicting AI doomsday trend has been pretty tiresome, and I'm glad it's getting push back. It's impossible to take it seriously given an Anthropic's CEO's incentives: to thrill investors and to shape regulation of competitors.

The biggest long term competitor to Anthropic isn't OpenAI, or Google... it's open source. That's the real target of Amodei's call for regulation.

Re: Nvidia CEO criticizes Anthropic boss over his statements on AI

#22
post #15

Just this morning, I had Claude come up with a C++ solution that would have undefined behavior that even a mid-level C++ dev could have easily caught (assuming iterator stability in a vector that was being modified) just by reading the code. These AI solutions are great, but I have yet to see any solution that makes me fear for my career. It just seems pretty clear that no LLM actually has a "mental model" of how thi…

a difference emerges when an agent can run code and examine the results. Most platforms are very cautious about this extension. Recent MCP does define toolsets and can enable these feedback loops in a way that can be adopted by markets and software ecosystems.

Re: Nvidia CEO criticizes Anthropic boss over his statements on AI

#23

Nvidia is also very mad about Anthropic's advocacy for chip export controls, which is not mentioned in this article. Dario has an entire blog post explaining why preventing China from getting Nvidia's top of the line chips is a critical national security issue, and Jensen is, at least by his public statements, furious about the export controls. As it currently stands, Anthropic is winning in terms of what the actual…

Jensen is right, though. If we force China to develop their own technology they’ll do that! We don’t have a monopoly on talent or resources. The US can have a stake at the table or nothing at all. The time when we, the US, could do protectionism without shooting ourselves in the foot is well and truly over. The most we can do is inconvenience China in the short term.

Re: Nvidia CEO criticizes Anthropic boss over his statements on AI

#24
post #15

Just this morning, I had Claude come up with a C++ solution that would have undefined behavior that even a mid-level C++ dev could have easily caught (assuming iterator stability in a vector that was being modified) just by reading the code. These AI solutions are great, but I have yet to see any solution that makes me fear for my career. It just seems pretty clear that no LLM actually has a "mental model" of how thi…

This is exactly right. LLMs do not build appropriate world models. And no...python and JS have similar failure cases.

Still, sometimes it can solve a problem like magic. But since it does not have a world model it is very unreliable, and you need to be able to fall back to real intelligence (i.e., yourself).

Re: Nvidia CEO criticizes Anthropic boss over his statements on AI

#25
Hey now, let's not criticize the Anthropic CEO just yet. He made a totally not just pulling a number out of his ass prediction, but a prediction that's nonetheless falsifiable.

> that 50% of all entry-level white-collar jobs could be wiped out by artificial intelligence, causing unemployment to jump to 20% within the next five years

I'm not a betting woman but I feel extremely confident taking the other end of this bet.

Re: Nvidia CEO criticizes Anthropic boss over his statements on AI

#26
post #8

Finally gave Claude a go after trying OpenAI a while and feeling pretty _meh_ about the coding ability... Wow, it's a whole other level or two ahead, at least for my daily flavor which is PowerShell. No way a double-digit amount of jobs aren't at stake. This stuff feels like it is really starting to take off. Incredible time to be in tech, but you gotta be clever and work hard every day to stay on the ride. Many folk…

I've been trying every flavor of AI powered development and after trying Claude Code for two days with an API key, I upgraded to the full Max 20x plan. Cursor, Windsurf, Roo Code / Cline, they're fine but nothing feels as thorough and useful to me as Claude Code. The Codex CLI from OpenAI is not bad either, there's just something satisfying about the LLM straight up using the CLI

hey can you explain the appeal of Claude Code vs Cursor?

I know the context window part and Cursor RAG-ing it, but isn't IDE integration a a true force multiplier?

Or does Claude Code do something similar with "send to chat" / smart (Cursor's TAB feature) autocomplete etc.?

I fired it up but it seemed like just Claude in terminal with a lot more manual copy-pasting expected?

I tried all the usual suspects in AI-assisted programming, and Cursor's TAB is too good to give up vs Roo / Cline.

I do agree Claude's the best for programming so would love to use it full-featured version.

Re: Nvidia CEO criticizes Anthropic boss over his statements on AI

#27

Strange to see such unfounded criticism directed at Anthropic and Dario. So far, they seem to be the most transparent and responsible in the AI race.

Anthropic's marketing has been successful at position them as the responsible alternative to OpenAI, but what concretely do they actually do differently than any other model provider?

It feels very akin to the Uber vs Lyft situation, two companies with very different perceptions pursuing identical business models

Re: Nvidia CEO criticizes Anthropic boss over his statements on AI

#28

Finally gave Claude a go after trying OpenAI a while and feeling pretty _meh_ about the coding ability... Wow, it's a whole other level or two ahead, at least for my daily flavor which is PowerShell. No way a double-digit amount of jobs aren't at stake. This stuff feels like it is really starting to take off. Incredible time to be in tech, but you gotta be clever and work hard every day to stay on the ride. Many folk…

I find it's good if you can get a really clean context, but on IRL problems with 100k+ lines of code that's extremely hard to manage.

It absolutely aced an old take-home test I had though - https://jamesmcm.github.io/blog/claude-data-engineer/

But note the problems it got wrong are troubling, especially the off-by-one error the first time as that's the sort of thing a human might not be able to validate easily.

Re: Nvidia CEO criticizes Anthropic boss over his statements on AI

#29
post #15

Just this morning, I had Claude come up with a C++ solution that would have undefined behavior that even a mid-level C++ dev could have easily caught (assuming iterator stability in a vector that was being modified) just by reading the code. These AI solutions are great, but I have yet to see any solution that makes me fear for my career. It just seems pretty clear that no LLM actually has a "mental model" of how thi…

This is where one can notice that LLM are, after all, just stochastic parrots. If we don't have a reliable way to systematically test their outputs, I don't see many jobs being replaced by AI either.

Re: Nvidia CEO criticizes Anthropic boss over his statements on AI

#30
post #12
post #9

Why look at five years and say "everything is gonna be fine in five years, thus, everything is gonna be fine and we should keep this AI thing going"? It's early days and nobody knows how things will go, but to me it looks that in the next century or so humans are going the way of the horse, at least when it comes to jobs. And if our society doesn't change radically, let's remember that the only way most people have o…

We have only been selling our labor for a couple of hundred years. Humanity has been around for hundreds of thousands of years. We will manage. Hey, we can always eat the rich!

"Dinosaurs have been around 100 million years and they will be around 100 million more" --Dinosaurs 65.1 million years ago.
Post reply on HN