Live data from Hacker News

Knowledge Management in the Age of AI

ericgardner.info

21–30 of 92 posts

Re: Knowledge Management in the Age of AI

#21
post #8

Earlier quoted context omitted.

They also sell a business license. I wonder how much money they make with that compared to the sync service.

I believe it's now free for commercial use. https://obsidian.md/blog/free-for-work/

Wow, I totally missed that. Very unexpected to me

Re: Knowledge Management in the Age of AI

#22
The author doesn't mention what I consider the true value of writing and organizing your notes yourself: that work is the work that drives learning and understanding.

I experimented with feeding my notes into an LLM model for RAG and was underwhelmed. The resulting output was repetitive, stilted, dry, and uninspiring. I wanted it to see if it find relationships between my ideas that I had not found on my own, but was disappointed . It did not provide me any new insights into my thinking. The style of what it did write was so foreign to my own style I found myself needing to read and re-interpret what it wrote back into my own ways of thinking that it was more busywork than help.

Re: Knowledge Management in the Age of AI

#23
post #18

I looked into Obsidian a few years ago but decided against it due to the lack of encryption and self-hosting options. Are there now any workarounds or solutions available that provide encryption and self-hosting capabilities?

We’re working on a new IDE but for tasks/notes [1] which is end-to-end-encrypted and optionally self-hostable

[1] https://thymer.com

Re: Knowledge Management in the Age of AI

#24
post #2

> Emacs is a powerful tool, but it also demands a lot from its user. Eventually I got tired of dealing with the host of plugins and customizations that I needed to keep my system running the way I wanted. I'm at a point in my life where I would rather spend my spare time on hobbies, hanging out with family and friends, and otherwise not messing around with a patchwork of ELisp code snippets that I've cobbled together…

Emacs is an incredible, powerful tool. It just lacks a decent editor.

Re: Knowledge Management in the Age of AI

#27
post #16

I am also worried a bit about knowledge nowadays. With LLM-based AI, should one also store individual chats in personal knowledge system? Yeah, I believe that some my chats are quite full of relevant info, that can be used in the future. Also what is the right general approach here - should I ask the same question several times (every time I need information) or should I just look up previous answer in my history? To…

slight tangent: google's search results are abysmal, strong recommendation to try kagi instead.

Re: Knowledge Management in the Age of AI

#28

Crazy coincidence as I just started setting up my PARA system on Logseq.

Yeah PARA is the new hype in knowledge management, those come and go (Zettelkasten, atomic notes...) I don't find PARA particularly useful. Using links and tags with no directories at all work much better for me. But I think that's the nice thing (and also the curse) of all of those you can spend your time biie shedding with the different versions of yourself in time instead of using it for your life.

Re: Knowledge Management in the Age of AI

#29
post #2

> Emacs is a powerful tool, but it also demands a lot from its user. Eventually I got tired of dealing with the host of plugins and customizations that I needed to keep my system running the way I wanted. I'm at a point in my life where I would rather spend my spare time on hobbies, hanging out with family and friends, and otherwise not messing around with a patchwork of ELisp code snippets that I've cobbled together…

I second this. Emacs is plenty capable out of the box and just fine that way. It's a "choose your own adventure" that allows you to be as disciplined or as reckless as you choose. It's almost like it grants you...freedom :)

I think this SO question demonstrates this well. The question is how to select a window quickly. You can install umpteen different packages and have several black-box soltions, if you want. But it really can be as simple as this if it fits your need:

``` ;; Select the 3rd window in the `window-list' (select-window (nth 2 (window-list))) ```

Emacs almost always allows you to find a solution in-between.

https://emacs.stackexchange.com/a/79692

Re: Knowledge Management in the Age of AI

#30
post #4

> Obsidian: An Org-Mode replacement? I doubt it. Obsidian is not open source, and the core is maintained by a small group of people, rather than a community. What happens when the company dies? That said, I am willing to have more faith in Obsidian, than many other things since they are not [VC funded]( https://stephango.com/vcware )

It doesn’t matter if Obsidian dies. The files are standard markdown you control and there is no lock-in. You can simply move on to another tool.
Post reply on HN