Live data from Hacker News

Cursor 1.0

cursor.com

21–30 of 492 posts

Re: Cursor 1.0

#21
post #7

VSCode with extensions Copilot [autocomplete] + CLINE [AI chat] + FOAM [obsidian-esk markdown support] is goat. There's no way a closed-source alternative to going to compete with this.

copilot autocomplete? my experience with it has been very delusional, cursor prediction in cursor(bad naming let's be honest) is simply unmatched

Re: Cursor 1.0

#22

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Have you given the alternatives a genuine test? My experience with Aider (never used Cline) is that it's nowhere near as good

Are you saying Aider isn't as good as Cursor, or that Cursor isn't as good as Aider?

aider isn't as good

Re: Cursor 1.0

#23
post #7

VSCode with extensions Copilot [autocomplete] + CLINE [AI chat] + FOAM [obsidian-esk markdown support] is goat. There's no way a closed-source alternative to going to compete with this.

copilot autocomplete? my experience with it has been very delusional, cursor prediction in cursor(bad naming let's be honest) is simply unmatched

Copilot in VSCode has autocomplete and also something they call "next edit".

In my experience, next edit is a significant net positive.

It fixes my typos and predicts next things I want to do in other lines of the same file.

For example, if I fix a variable scope from a loop, it automatically scans for similar mistakes nearby and suggests. Editing multiple array values is also intuitive. It will also learn and suggest formatting prefences and other things such as API changes.

Sure, sometimes it suggests things I don't want but on average it is productive to me.

Re: Cursor 1.0

#24
I keep getting back and forth between Cursor and Zed, but Cursor autocomplete and next cursor prediction are still the best in class between all the competitors, I don't use chats and agents, yet I feel very productive and fast. I sometimes go back to Copilot too just to see how is it going but it has been very delusional so far regarding code suggestions. The only thing I hate about Cursor is the overwrite of some of the shortcuts of vscode, I remapped some and learned some new, and that vim mode plugin is a bit buggy. This and the fact that performance compared with Zed is shit and that's why I go back to Zed sometimes, I'm pondering the idea of just using both and keep them both open

Re: Cursor 1.0

#25
post #23

Earlier quoted context omitted.

copilot autocomplete? my experience with it has been very delusional, cursor prediction in cursor(bad naming let's be honest) is simply unmatched

Copilot in VSCode has autocomplete and also something they call "next edit". In my experience, next edit is a significant net positive. It fixes my typos and predicts next things I want to do in other lines of the same file. For example, if I fix a variable scope from a loop, it automatically scans for similar mistakes nearby and suggests. Editing multiple array values is also intuitive. It will also learn and sugges…

Cursor also does this.

Re: Cursor 1.0

#26
post #7

VSCode with extensions Copilot [autocomplete] + CLINE [AI chat] + FOAM [obsidian-esk markdown support] is goat. There's no way a closed-source alternative to going to compete with this.

What does "is goat" mean?

Re: Cursor 1.0

#27

I love Cursor, but it feels like a ticking time bomb with extensions not being updated at the same rate as VSCode. Also another issue I am starting to see is the lack of shared MCP servers. If I have VSCode, Cursor, and Claude open, each one is running its own instance of the MCP server. You can imagine that with a dozen or so MCP's, the memory footprint becomes quite large for no reason.

why would you open 3 IDEs all at once :-)

Re: Cursor 1.0

#28
post #7

VSCode with extensions Copilot [autocomplete] + CLINE [AI chat] + FOAM [obsidian-esk markdown support] is goat. There's no way a closed-source alternative to going to compete with this.

What does "is goat" mean?

Goat is slang for “(the) greatest of all time.”

Re: Cursor 1.0

#30
post #8
post #5

Cursor recently lost me as a customer. Too many updates that disturb my workflow and productivity, no easy way to roll back versions, super sparse changelogs, lots of magic in context building, really untransparent pricing on max mode. I recently made the switch to Claude Code on the Max plan and I couldn't be happier. The only real thing I'm missing is the diff view across files, but I assume it's just a matter of t…

I feel unstoppable with Claude Code Max. I never thought I'd pay $200 per month for any developer tool, yet here we are, and I also couldn't be happier with it.

Would you pay $400?
Post reply on HN