Live data from Hacker News

Probabilistic Artificial Intelligence

arxiv.org

21–30 of 100 posts

Re: Probabilistic Artificial Intelligence

#21
Seems similar, or at least partially overlap, with what I would say is the best reference on the subject, an Introduction to Statistical Learning from Gareth James et al [1].

I wonder it this one might be a bit more accessible, although I guess the R/Python examples are helpful on the latter.

[1] https://www.statlearning.com/

Re: Probabilistic Artificial Intelligence

#22
The text has some great explanatory diagrams and looks to be a very high quality overview of ML thru the lens of probability, with lots of math.

I was also recently impressed by Zhaos "Mathematical Foundation of Reinforcement Learning", free textbook and video lectures on YT : https://github.com/MathFoundationRL/Book-Mathematical-Founda...

If you dont have a lot of time, at least glance at Zhaos overview contents diagram, its a good conceptual map of the whole field, imo .. here :

https://github.com/MathFoundationRL/Book-Mathematical-Founda...

and maybe watch the intro video.

Re: Probabilistic Artificial Intelligence

#23

Seems similar, or at least partially overlap, with what I would say is the best reference on the subject, an Introduction to Statistical Learning from Gareth James et al [1]. I wonder it this one might be a bit more accessible, although I guess the R/Python examples are helpful on the latter. [1] https://www.statlearning.com/

not really, islr is a pretty basic book - this is about more advanced techniques to propagate probability estimates rather than point-wise

and frankly i would not recommend islr anymore today, too dated

Re: Probabilistic Artificial Intelligence

#24
I took this class at ETH Zurich and it is one of my favorite classes. Especially how do you quantify uncertainty and how they build the starting blocks of reinforcement learning. I think it’s an excellent read for data scientists and ML engineers.

This document is the lecture notes.

Re: Probabilistic Artificial Intelligence

#25

I think we’ll need a GUI for the models to democratize interpretability and let even gamers explore them. Basically to train another model, that will take the LLM and convert it into 3D shapes and put them in some 3D world that is understandable for humans. Simpler example: represent an LLM as a green field with objects, where humans are the only agents: You stand near a monkey, see chewing mouth nearby, go there (yo…

I dont think anyone has found a good way to map higher dimensional space onto 4D visualizations, yet.

Maybe this is why tokens and language are so useful for humans ? they might be the closest analog we have.

Re: Probabilistic Artificial Intelligence

#26
post #3
post #2

This is great. Is it available as a printed book?

From a brief search I see that it isn't (or it least not yet), but seeing how well-formatted the pdf is, and the fact that it's CC-licensed, you could print it yourself, or perhaps talk with them to organize a batch. Though I personally prefer to read these sorts of books directly from pdf, and am grateful to them for sharing it on arxiv.

I wonder if they're aiming for it to be a book. Hubotter describes it on his web page as "notes on Probabilistic AI".

Re: Probabilistic Artificial Intelligence

#27

Seems similar, or at least partially overlap, with what I would say is the best reference on the subject, an Introduction to Statistical Learning from Gareth James et al [1]. I wonder it this one might be a bit more accessible, although I guess the R/Python examples are helpful on the latter. [1] https://www.statlearning.com/

not really, islr is a pretty basic book - this is about more advanced techniques to propagate probability estimates rather than point-wise and frankly i would not recommend islr anymore today, too dated

What would you (or other informed parties) recommend?

Re: Probabilistic Artificial Intelligence

#28
post #20

Books suck (imho). We need a new format to teach and learn this deep technical stuff. Not youtube, something interactive with exercises and engagement.

yeah, I mean 3Blue1Brown has done a great job .. and maybe those would be even better if you could app-ify them into something you can interact with.

Current gen of LLM programming AIs might make it less leg-work to make these

Re: Probabilistic Artificial Intelligence

#29

I think we’ll need a GUI for the models to democratize interpretability and let even gamers explore them. Basically to train another model, that will take the LLM and convert it into 3D shapes and put them in some 3D world that is understandable for humans. Simpler example: represent an LLM as a green field with objects, where humans are the only agents: You stand near a monkey, see chewing mouth nearby, go there (yo…

I had a mind-bending Salvia trip at eighteen that went sort of like that. My mind turned into an infinitely large department store where each aisle was a concurrent branch of thought, and the common ingredient lists above each aisle were populated with words, feelings and concepts related to each branch. The PA system replaced my internal monologue, which I no longer had, but instead I was hearing my thoughts externa…

“When I began to navigate psychospace with LSD, I realized that before we were conscious, seemingly self-propelled human beings, many tapes and corridors had been created in our minds and reflexes which were not of our own making. These patterns and tapes laid down in our consciousness are walled off from each other. I see it as a vast labyrinth with high walls sealing off the many directives created by our personal history.

Many of these directives are contradictory. The coexistence of these contradictory programs is what we call inner conflict. This conflict causes us to constantly check ourselves while we are caught in the opposition of polarity. Another metaphor would be like a computer with many programs running simultaneously. The more programs that are running, the slower the computer functions. This is a problem then. With all the programs running that are demanded of our consciousness in this modern world, we have problems finding deep integration.

To complicate matters, the programs are reinforced by fear. Fear separates, love integrates. We find ourselves drawn to love and unity, but afraid to make the leap.

What I found to be the genius of LSD is that it really gets you high, higher than the programs, higher than the walls that mask and blind one to the energy destroying presence of many contradictory but hidden programs. When LSD is used intentionally it enables you to see all the tracks laid down, to explore each one intensely. It also allows you to see the many parallel and redundant programs as well as the contradictory ones.

It allows you to see the underlying unity of all opposites in the magic play of existence. This allows you to edit these programs and recreate superior programs that give you the insight to shake loose the restrictions and conflicts programmed into each one of us by our parents, our religion, our early education, and by society as a whole.”

~ Nick Sand, 2001, Mind States conference, quoted in Casey Hardison's obituary

Re: Probabilistic Artificial Intelligence

#30

Earlier quoted context omitted.

not really, islr is a pretty basic book - this is about more advanced techniques to propagate probability estimates rather than point-wise and frankly i would not recommend islr anymore today, too dated

What would you (or other informed parties) recommend?

it’s been a while since I’ve been a beginner so I might not have the best resources, but I would recommend Harvard’s Stat 110 with Joe Blitzstein (lectures online) and then Machine Learning by Kevin Murphy. might be a scarier book to someone not confident in their math, but overall a better one imo

for something more directly comparable to the niche ISLR filled, Bishop’s books are generally better - although I can’t recall their title

Post reply on HN