Live data from Hacker News

Signal to leave Sweden if backdoor law passes

swedenherald.com

21–30 of 283 posts

Re: Signal to leave Sweden if backdoor law passes

#21

It seems like a lot of these proposals are coming out of Europe—assuming I’m not mistaken (and I may well be), why is Europe cracking down so much on privacy?

European bureaucrats generally have little understanding of the technology they get paid to regulate, as we've seen with the their previous attempts to regulate the industry. It's very much a "vibes-based" approach. They can simply keep proposing the same regulation with a new name until it's voted through.

Re: Signal to leave Sweden if backdoor law passes

#23

[flagged]

> Or do they want us to believe 3-letter U.S. agencies don't have access to Signal right now? Is this some publicity stunt? [Citation needed]

I believe the citation falls under "street smarts" as the WikiLeaks press release mentioned Signal explicitly. Whether this was a subtle outing the origin of the tool itself is left as an exercise for the reader.

Regardless, the threat vector is accessing the data before encryption anyway. And drawing attention to yourself by running certain apps and services in the first place.

There's a lot of mathematicians in maryland and those who studied the history often land on "if they want you, they got you."

Re: Signal to leave Sweden if backdoor law passes

#25
post #7
post #2

You know it's a banger proposal when even the Swedish armed forces tells you "Please don't".

They haven’t been in a war since 1814, so they’ve had lots of time to develop other competences. I hear they also make amazing sourdough and can discuss the Beatles catalog at depth.

as a general rule countries that succeed with a policy of neutrality do so by having their military strong enough that they're mot worth fucking with.

Re: Signal to leave Sweden if backdoor law passes

#27
post #24
post #4

Unlike a certain big tech giant who pretends to care about privacy until it cuts into their profits.

All of them?

Well, only some claim to "remain committed to offering our users the highest level of security for their personal data" while turning off E2EE cloud storage for an entire country.

Re: Signal to leave Sweden if backdoor law passes

#28
post #3

> The Armed Forces, on the other hand, are negative and write in a letter to the government that the proposal cannot be realized "without introducing vulnerabilities and backdoors that can be exploited by third parties First time I am seeing an organization against this. Kudos to them for standing up.

Apple took the same stance during the San Bernardino case!

Re: Signal to leave Sweden if backdoor law passes

#29
post #24

Earlier quoted context omitted.

All of them?

Well, only some claim to "remain committed to offering our users the highest level of security for their personal data" while turning off E2EE cloud storage for an entire country.

What else could they have done?
Post reply on HN