Live data from Hacker News

How hucksters are manipulating Google to promote shady Chrome extensions

arstechnica.com

21–30 of 62 posts

Re: How hucksters are manipulating Google to promote shady Chrome extensions

#21
post #13

I have two Chrome extensions in the store. They're not very popular and are really just features I wanted for my own use. I think I have less than 100 users total. At least once a week I get emails from people - offering money to add their "tracking" code - wanting to purchased the extension outright What they clearly want is access to my modest install base to push questionable code onto. I certainly am not going fo…

How much were they offering?

Re: How hucksters are manipulating Google to promote shady Chrome extensions

#22
post #13

I have two Chrome extensions in the store. They're not very popular and are really just features I wanted for my own use. I think I have less than 100 users total. At least once a week I get emails from people - offering money to add their "tracking" code - wanting to purchased the extension outright What they clearly want is access to my modest install base to push questionable code onto. I certainly am not going fo…

Did they seem personalized or do they just mass-mail every developer they can find? 100 users seem very little to go through the trouble of acquiring an extension and then push bad code. Did they ever give you an idea of what they are ready to pay?

They seem pretty generic, like spray and pray. I am sure they just scrape all the developers details from the Chrome Store and bug them all.

I don't seem to have saved any of them but I do recall one offering me $6,400 for my extension because there was a small voice in the back of my head whispering "that's a lot of money..."

Most of the ones wanting me to install code offer ongoing payments.

Re: How hucksters are manipulating Google to promote shady Chrome extensions

#23
post #13

I have two Chrome extensions in the store. They're not very popular and are really just features I wanted for my own use. I think I have less than 100 users total. At least once a week I get emails from people - offering money to add their "tracking" code - wanting to purchased the extension outright What they clearly want is access to my modest install base to push questionable code onto. I certainly am not going fo…

Did you see what the tracking code does? If possible, it'll be useful to get access to this.

Re: How hucksters are manipulating Google to promote shady Chrome extensions

#24
post #13

I have two Chrome extensions in the store. They're not very popular and are really just features I wanted for my own use. I think I have less than 100 users total. At least once a week I get emails from people - offering money to add their "tracking" code - wanting to purchased the extension outright What they clearly want is access to my modest install base to push questionable code onto. I certainly am not going fo…

How much were they offering?

They're not really targeting particular extension. Most people probably don't want to sell anyway so they would just waste time. They send email to everyone who have extension and then when any developer replies, only then they decide if they even want to buy. I have extension with 50k installs in last 5 years that has always on full access to visited pages (content script) and they offered $2k.

Re: How hucksters are manipulating Google to promote shady Chrome extensions

#25
post #24

Earlier quoted context omitted.

How much were they offering?

They're not really targeting particular extension. Most people probably don't want to sell anyway so they would just waste time. They send email to everyone who have extension and then when any developer replies, only then they decide if they even want to buy. I have extension with 50k installs in last 5 years that has always on full access to visited pages (content script) and they offered $2k.

$2k seems abysmally low to throw away your labor of love and compromise your morals. At least in the US

Re: How hucksters are manipulating Google to promote shady Chrome extensions

#26

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Small info piece: Chrome isn't open source. Otherwise I agree (even if it means agreeing with Peter Thiel in this case).

Well shiver me timbers, if that isn't a hoot. Maybe my vernacular is off, "source available" ? ah "licensed freeware" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Google_Chrome

chromium is open source, chrome is chromium + proprietary stuff added on top

Re: How hucksters are manipulating Google to promote shady Chrome extensions

#27

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'm not sure I buy Thiel's argument becuase plenty of their non-search businesses such as Google Cloud, GSuite, Waymo, and Verily have become pretty successful in their own right, and vertical integration is another form of monopoly that tends to cracked down on.

If I had a monopoly on sugar and traded in silver and healthcare, I would still have a monopoly on sugar.

Yea but diversification is a critical business strategy not just a marketing ploy

Re: How hucksters are manipulating Google to promote shady Chrome extensions

#28
post #25
post #24

Earlier quoted context omitted.

They're not really targeting particular extension. Most people probably don't want to sell anyway so they would just waste time. They send email to everyone who have extension and then when any developer replies, only then they decide if they even want to buy. I have extension with 50k installs in last 5 years that has always on full access to visited pages (content script) and they offered $2k.

$2k seems abysmally low to throw away your labor of love and compromise your morals. At least in the US

you're making some assumptions that every dev has morals, and that some unscrupulous dev didn't build the thing specifically in hopes of getting this offer

Re: How hucksters are manipulating Google to promote shady Chrome extensions

#29

> Apparently, some extension authors figured out that the Chrome Web Store search index is shared across all languages Oh, you mean like google ads and android app ads? Because both think I'm either Chinese or Korean, despite being neither.

Targeting at its finest.

Re: How hucksters are manipulating Google to promote shady Chrome extensions

#30

These rogue extensions are "surreptitiously monetizing web searches" - but doesn't Google conspicuously monetize web searches? So it seems the Google TOS bans competition in search monetization using their "open source" browser. Isn't it odd that an "open source" browser is apparently designed to provide a monopoly on search monetization by the nice people who give it to you for free? And being 80% or so of all searc…

The competition is a click away.
Post reply on HN