Live data from Hacker News

Settlement for Australian users impacted by Cambridge Analytica incident

oaic.gov.au

21–30 of 41 posts

Re: Settlement for Australian users impacted by Cambridge Analytica incident

#21
post #7

Kinda weird. We (Australia) have a new major data breach every month. Seems strange to single out Meta, what about Optus, St Vincent’s, Dymocks, the AFP (!), the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (hardly surpising, with their 1990s website), Pizza Hut, the Royal Women’s Hospital, and about 100 (not hyperbole) others?

Because it’s harder to prosecute incompetence.

Re: Settlement for Australian users impacted by Cambridge Analytica incident

#22
post #7

Kinda weird. We (Australia) have a new major data breach every month. Seems strange to single out Meta, what about Optus, St Vincent’s, Dymocks, the AFP (!), the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (hardly surpising, with their 1990s website), Pizza Hut, the Royal Women’s Hospital, and about 100 (not hyperbole) others?

My understanding is that the difference is that the Meta-Cambridge Analytica situation wasn't a 'hack' data breach, it was Facebook sharing data in breach of existing Australian privacy laws.

ie. Meta is at fault, as opposed to a criminal intruder.

Re: Settlement for Australian users impacted by Cambridge Analytica incident

#23
post #17

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The Australian government is targeting Meta on a wide range of issues and will keep doing so until they transfer more money to news oligarchs to compensate them for "loss of business model".

This is how you know the (old) media mongrels have bought out the australian gov't. I am vehemently against it, but no matter which party you choose to vote for, the result has been the same.

Whilst I agree with the sentiment, most definitely in the case of social networks funding old media for the privilege of linking to their news sources, I think in this case Meta "did something egregiously wrong" that was also illegal according to Australian privacy law.

(Aside: An amusing thought experiment is how voraciously would the Australian government pursue Murdoch's media empire had it committed a similar act? A $50 million fine would kill it's Australian enterprise, or at least be nearly-fatal, I'd hope...)

Re: Settlement for Australian users impacted by Cambridge Analytica incident

#24

Earlier quoted context omitted.

We (Australia) have no enforceable privacy legislation. The choice to single out Meta is probably political, though could also be about scale, and being a huge foreign company with deep pockets.

>[...]personal information of some Australian Facebook users was disclosed to the This is Your Digital Life app in breach of the Privacy Act 1988 (Cth). The information was exposed to the risk of disclosure to Cambridge Analytica and other third parties, and risked being used for political profiling purposes. [...] The relevant law had been in force for two decades before facebook ever became relevant.

I think this is the first actual settlement in the 20 years those rules have been on the books?

Re: Settlement for Australian users impacted by Cambridge Analytica incident

#25
post #17

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This is how you know the (old) media mongrels have bought out the australian gov't. I am vehemently against it, but no matter which party you choose to vote for, the result has been the same.

Whilst I agree with the sentiment, most definitely in the case of social networks funding old media for the privilege of linking to their news sources, I think in this case Meta "did something egregiously wrong" that was also illegal according to Australian privacy law. (Aside: An amusing thought experiment is how voraciously would the Australian government pursue Murdoch's media empire had it committed a similar act…

[deleted]

Re: Settlement for Australian users impacted by Cambridge Analytica incident

#26
post #16

How do you know if a friend installed This is Your Digital Life?

There's a link you can go to when you're logged in to Facebook and it tells you. It came back that none of my FB friends had used it for me.

I wonder where this link can be found?

Re: Settlement for Australian users impacted by Cambridge Analytica incident

#28
post #17

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The Australian government is targeting Meta on a wide range of issues and will keep doing so until they transfer more money to news oligarchs to compensate them for "loss of business model".

This is how you know the (old) media mongrels have bought out the australian gov't. I am vehemently against it, but no matter which party you choose to vote for, the result has been the same.

the greens could always use more votes

Re: Settlement for Australian users impacted by Cambridge Analytica incident

#29
post #7

Kinda weird. We (Australia) have a new major data breach every month. Seems strange to single out Meta, what about Optus, St Vincent’s, Dymocks, the AFP (!), the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (hardly surpising, with their 1990s website), Pizza Hut, the Royal Women’s Hospital, and about 100 (not hyperbole) others?

My understanding is that the difference is that the Meta-Cambridge Analytica situation wasn't a 'hack' data breach, it was Facebook sharing data in breach of existing Australian privacy laws. ie. Meta is at fault, as opposed to a criminal intruder.

It was an API. After years of getting shit for not opening their social graph. To this day I don't understand how the world decided that was a big deal.

Re: Settlement for Australian users impacted by Cambridge Analytica incident

#30
post #9

How are we supposed to know if someone in our network used the 'This is Your Digital Life app'? I feel like there is so much more behind this. Personally, I feel like I've been secretly blacklisted for 5 years straight. Even LLMs are telling me that it seems like I've been blacklisted and that it appears like there is 'an element of coordination' when I describe some of the bizarre work experiences that I've had in t…

You can check with this support article; you need to be logged in to a Facebook account.

https://www.facebook.com/help/1873665312923476

Post reply on HN