Live data from Hacker News

Oligarchs now in full control of America? What does Hacker News think of this?

news.ycombinator.com

21–30 of 31 posts

Re: Oligarchs now in full control of America? What does Hacker News think of this?

#21
post #8

This day has been decades in the making. I'm thinking 1,000 years from now they'll pinpoint the start of the transition of America from a democracy to whatever it is we're transitioning to as starting with the Nixon administration. One thing I think you're feeling is the end of the post-war period. WWII shaped global politics for the latter half of the 20th century. Not to put too fine of a point on it, but that war…

Returning to 70 years ago would involve an upper income tax rate of 91% and (as far as I can gather) 25% on capital gains tax

Re: Oligarchs now in full control of America? What does Hacker News think of this?

#22
from the 2020 presidential election, Forbes has a 4-part series about the billionaires that donated to Biden and Trump.

Part 1: https://www.forbes.com/sites/michelatindera/2021/02/15/biden...

    Four months later, when the campaign ended, Trump finished with 133 billionaire backers who collectively gave him $37.8 million. Biden, meanwhile, had 230 donors who contributed $39.1 million.

    Those sums only tell part of the story, though. Many of the biggest donors to the campaigns also funneled huge amounts into super-PACs supporting the two candidates. Super-PACs cannot coordinate with campaigns, which is why Forbes did not count those funds as part of the totals raised by Biden or Trump. But the groups, which are allowed to raise unlimited sums, can nonetheless plow money into television ads that support a candidate.

Re: Oligarchs now in full control of America? What does Hacker News think of this?

#23
post #9
post #3

Oligarchs have always had full control in America. They've chosen to exercise that in an especially conspicuous way, but in the end, a bunch of people went into the voting booth and pulled the lever labeled "felon". The oligarchs have a huge thumb on the scale, but it's not mind control. As Mencken said, "Democracy is the theory that the common people know what they want, and deserve to get it good and hard." Maybe w…

This is also a source of great frustration to me. That so many people discounted the character issue when many who worked directly with him including his own former VP, Chief of Staff and military leaders said that his character issues disqualified him for the job is amazing to me. My motto for the rest of the year and going forward is to no longer try to understand the actions of others, but to just accept. Peoples…

That many people from his previous administration and own party coming out against his character issues? It's unprecedented. Mind boggling.

Plus January 6th and all his legal problems(plus convictions). That whole government documents circus.

And we have collectively looked past this and put him back in office? He won the GOP PRIMARY?! I know people aren't "feeling the economy vibes" but dang.

Re: Oligarchs now in full control of America? What does Hacker News think of this?

#24

Honestly, after a brief bit of despair, I took a hard look at what Trump supporters were saying and particularly the priorities and beliefs of people in the demographics that shifted in his favor and I think there's a clear path to Democrat victories in the future. This election shouldn't be understood as some sort of "the oligarchs won", but rather that the American voters have signaled that they're "anti-woke" to t…

The average voter doesn't spend their days thinking about woke. That's chronically online behavior.

The top issues voters mentioned and has been correlated with voting behavior this round was the economy.

Re: Oligarchs now in full control of America? What does Hacker News think of this?

#26
post #23
post #9

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This is also a source of great frustration to me. That so many people discounted the character issue when many who worked directly with him including his own former VP, Chief of Staff and military leaders said that his character issues disqualified him for the job is amazing to me. My motto for the rest of the year and going forward is to no longer try to understand the actions of others, but to just accept. Peoples…

That many people from his previous administration and own party coming out against his character issues? It's unprecedented. Mind boggling. Plus January 6th and all his legal problems(plus convictions). That whole government documents circus. And we have collectively looked past this and put him back in office? He won the GOP PRIMARY?! I know people aren't "feeling the economy vibes" but dang.

I'm not really convinced of the "economy" argument. It's easy to make, but there is no reason to think that the other guy is actually any better. They may not be thrilled with where they are now, but they were not noticeably better off four years ago.

Some are worse off; some are better; many are about the same. It's just not sufficient to explain electing a literal criminal.

I'm sure it figures in somewhere, but I don't think it's anywhere near enough to explain the situation.

Re: Oligarchs now in full control of America? What does Hacker News think of this?

#27
Oligarchs or technocrats. In the end you see the 1000 odd people in government and they are not islands . Some people will befriend them (oligarchs and technocrats) and of course they are at the very top of the Maslow pyramid of needs and so of course they'd bond over their opinions about "how society should work to maximize welfare"

Re: Oligarchs now in full control of America? What does Hacker News think of this?

#28
post #26
post #23

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That many people from his previous administration and own party coming out against his character issues? It's unprecedented. Mind boggling. Plus January 6th and all his legal problems(plus convictions). That whole government documents circus. And we have collectively looked past this and put him back in office? He won the GOP PRIMARY?! I know people aren't "feeling the economy vibes" but dang.

I'm not really convinced of the "economy" argument. It's easy to make, but there is no reason to think that the other guy is actually any better. They may not be thrilled with where they are now, but they were not noticeably better off four years ago. Some are worse off; some are better; many are about the same. It's just not sufficient to explain electing a literal criminal . I'm sure it figures in somewhere, but I…

They've mapped polls showing economy being the biggest voter issue and correlated that with voter behavior.

Also, they mapped the counties highest hit by wages trailing inflation in PA.. They flipped for Trump from Biden this round.

It's a referendum on the current party in office, so people just want change and that was promised to them heavily by Trump.

But man.. Trump wasn't the only other choice. There was a whole GOP primary lol.

Re: Oligarchs now in full control of America? What does Hacker News think of this?

#30
post #8

This day has been decades in the making. I'm thinking 1,000 years from now they'll pinpoint the start of the transition of America from a democracy to whatever it is we're transitioning to as starting with the Nixon administration. One thing I think you're feeling is the end of the post-war period. WWII shaped global politics for the latter half of the 20th century. Not to put too fine of a point on it, but that war…

Returning to 70 years ago would involve an upper income tax rate of 91% and (as far as I can gather) 25% on capital gains tax

Almost nobody who voted for Trump was an adult during this timeframe. They were a teen or a child, if they were alive at all. People pining for the past always look at the past through rose-colored glasses. People don't think about the high taxes and a world whose manufacturing output was ravaged by war contributed to the American economic success story.

People almost never talk about the marginalized living at that time. Those unpleasantries are filtered out by those rose-colored glasses! Populists like Trump certainly never mention the realities of the time. They leverage people's fantasies of a by-gone era.

So no, they really don't want what they wish for, and by the time they've realized what they've wished for and what they've done, it'll be too late.

Post reply on HN