Live data from Hacker News

Skrollr - parallax scrolling for the masses

prinzhorn.github.com

21–30 of 48 posts

Re: Skrollr - parallax scrolling for the masses

#21

It's a neat demo of some very nice capabilities, but let us please not go back to the Flash era circa 2002 where designers tried to make their navigation as nauseating as possible. Or put another way, its worth remembering that just because you can incorporate all of these effects does not mean you should. Some designs can be very disorienting to some people.

It would be kind of a boring demo if they just showed some very subtle and barely noticeable effects. ;)

Re: Skrollr - parallax scrolling for the masses

#25

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I didn't think of that - I actually have a Logitech mouse where I can switch between the clicking scrolling and the freewheeling.

Even then, in Windows, you can't scroll pixel by pixel can you? I'm not sure if you're familiar with Apple touchpads, but I've never seen anything emulate their ability to scroll at literally continuous increments. Even with my Logitech (that also switches) "free wheeling" still has a minimum increment. It's configurable, but it's just "jumping" relative to the Apple Trackpad mechanic.

Click and hold the center mouse button (scroll wheel). Notice the four arrows that pop up. While still holding the center button down, move the mouse up/down, and you'll scroll smoothly. I use this whenever I'm away from my mac.

Re: Skrollr - parallax scrolling for the masses

#26
post #25

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Even then, in Windows, you can't scroll pixel by pixel can you? I'm not sure if you're familiar with Apple touchpads, but I've never seen anything emulate their ability to scroll at literally continuous increments. Even with my Logitech (that also switches) "free wheeling" still has a minimum increment. It's configurable, but it's just "jumping" relative to the Apple Trackpad mechanic.

Click and hold the center mouse button (scroll wheel). Notice the four arrows that pop up. While still holding the center button down, move the mouse up/down, and you'll scroll smoothly. I use this whenever I'm away from my mac.

Well now I feel sufficiently stupid. I haven't used that in ages, even at work or on my desktop. Hm.

Re: Skrollr - parallax scrolling for the masses

#27
I think if this is used with appropriate limitations and caution, it can add to a site's presence in a positive way. All the UI concerns already listed are definitely valid, though - it's easy to take this too far.

There are quite a few decent parallax scripts/libs out there, but most of them rely on scrolling (like Skrollr) or cursor position tracking (github's 404 page). Am I the only one who likes to be able to page through parallax with buttons?

Re: Skrollr - parallax scrolling for the masses

#28

I have yet to receive a request for parallax. And we I do I will kindly point them in the direction of any marketing firm who knows nothing about usability or implementation.

The same ones that put contact information in an image so you can't select and copy it, and hide that image behind a transparent div, so you can't even download it. Ugh.

Re: Skrollr - parallax scrolling for the masses

#29
post #21

It's a neat demo of some very nice capabilities, but let us please not go back to the Flash era circa 2002 where designers tried to make their navigation as nauseating as possible. Or put another way, its worth remembering that just because you can incorporate all of these effects does not mean you should. Some designs can be very disorienting to some people.

It would be kind of a boring demo if they just showed some very subtle and barely noticeable effects. ;)

I think he wasn't referring to the demo itself, which obviously should show off as many nauseating effects as it has, but to future devs who might use this library.

Re: Skrollr - parallax scrolling for the masses

#30

I get whole screen "blink"s on OSX 10.7 chrome 19, especially in the beginning when boxes of text are moving in an out. Just when you think one is out, it flashes in for a second and disappears. Probably an off-by-1 or something?

It seems a little broken (and flickery) on Chrome in OS X. It worked great in Firefox and Safari.
Post reply on HN