Live data from Hacker News

Family poisoned after using AI-generated mushroom identification book

old.reddit.com

21–30 of 123 posts

Re: Family poisoned after using AI-generated mushroom identification book

#21
post #19

I see this happen a lot on Tiktok and Facebook where influencers post about using different plants for food or for skincare. They often either show photos that are of a different plant that is dangerous to eat or they haven’t actually tried this and promoting the consumption of a plant that can poison people. It’s the Wild West out there on social networks.

Obligatory PA Comic: https://www.penny-arcade.com/comic/2024/05/27/a-very-particu...

Re: Family poisoned after using AI-generated mushroom identification book

#22
post #3

Do we believe this story? It's a Reddit "LegalAdvice" thread. It's not morel season in the UK right now; false morels are also March-May produce.

Yeah, while this story is absolutely plausible, plausible does not necessarily mean true. OP is a new account with suspiciously few details that would permit fact-checking, and I think I'd call this one ragebait until proven otherwise. (That does not mean that this couldn't happen or that there isn't a risk of it happening, but everyone here hopefully knew that before this thread. I'm saying it shouldn't adjust your beliefs much if at all.)

Re: Family poisoned after using AI-generated mushroom identification book

#24
post #13

This was something that was bound to happen and is going to happen again unless we get more serious regulation around AI publishing. > It lists the author as having a Masters Degree in Mycology from University of East Ontario. A search later revealed there is no "University of East Ontario." This has got to be criminal negligence.

What's good for the goose is good for the gander: the AI generated not only the contents but the author as well. This has to be some kind of a new level of idiocy. I mean, use AI to make junk sci-fi stories, and generate fake authors all day. But going for a book about mushrooms deserves a special stupidity and evilness award.

[deleted]

Re: Family poisoned after using AI-generated mushroom identification book

#25

This was something that was bound to happen and is going to happen again unless we get more serious regulation around AI publishing. > It lists the author as having a Masters Degree in Mycology from University of East Ontario. A search later revealed there is no "University of East Ontario." This has got to be criminal negligence.

Sounds more like a scam.

Re: Family poisoned after using AI-generated mushroom identification book

#26
post #20

This is actually a problem with non-AI generated mushroom books as well. Apparently publishers have been copying eachothers misinformation for a long time.

It is also a problem with accurate images and descriptions. Some mushrooms are very easily mistaken for others: unless you're 100% sure you've picked this very species before in around the same place and time, you'd better leave it there or bring it to a mycologist for identification.

How long until dna tests become cheap and available enough to use for mushroom identification? I wonder what that will do to the hobby...

Re: Family poisoned after using AI-generated mushroom identification book

#27
post #5
post #3

Do we believe this story? It's a Reddit "LegalAdvice" thread. It's not morel season in the UK right now; false morels are also March-May produce.

The poster doesn’t claim they ate morels. The section about morels was an example for something unrelated to the poisoning.

The fact that these people claim mushroom poisoning but don't say what kind of mushrooms they were looking for makes you... more? less? willing to buy the story?

They mentioned morels, which are sort of plausible (dates excepted) since false morels aren't going to kill you. What kind of mushroom would they be hunting in late July where their poisoning wouldn't be actually-newsworthy?

Re: Family poisoned after using AI-generated mushroom identification book

#28
post #15
post #3

Do we believe this story? It's a Reddit "LegalAdvice" thread. It's not morel season in the UK right now; false morels are also March-May produce.

I searched for the title of the book and nothing came up. When does searching for something NOT bring up amazon links?

> The book is entitled something similar to: "Mushrooms UK: A Guide to Harvesting Safe and Edible Mushrooms."

> The book has been removed from sale from the online retailer, ...

Emphasis added. I don't know if this is real or not, but they haven't given us the title.

Re: Family poisoned after using AI-generated mushroom identification book

#29
post #20

This is actually a problem with non-AI generated mushroom books as well. Apparently publishers have been copying eachothers misinformation for a long time.

It is also a problem with accurate images and descriptions. Some mushrooms are very easily mistaken for others: unless you're 100% sure you've picked this very species before in around the same place and time, you'd better leave it there or bring it to a mycologist for identification.

I agree, I always thought eating mushrooms required an expert for confirmation, otherwise you are rolling the dice. Buying a random book off Amazon and using that seems like the very definition of something a non-expert would do.

Re: Family poisoned after using AI-generated mushroom identification book

#30
post #3

Do we believe this story? It's a Reddit "LegalAdvice" thread. It's not morel season in the UK right now; false morels are also March-May produce.

There have been quite a few articles corroborating the existence of books like this, the only part that needs believing is that someone actually used the books as advertised. https://www.vox.com/24141648/ai-ebook-grift-mushroom-foragin... https://fortune.com/2023/09/03/ai-written-mushroom-hunting-g...

The fact that this exact thing has received media coverage increases the likelihood that the post is fake.

Of course the story remains plausible, and it certainly has an air of truthiness, but I'd give it very good odds for being fake.

Post reply on HN