Live data from Hacker News

UK man imprisoned for 4 months after walking up to cops with 6" Master Sword

pcgamer.com

21–30 of 33 posts

Re: UK man imprisoned for 4 months after walking up to cops with 6" Master Sword

#21
For everyone freaking out over this:

It's a 6 inch metal blade, and he was walking along a public street, holding it unsheathed in front of him. He still had it out in front of him when he approached the police and they arrested him.

I'd expect the same thing for any 6 inch blade being brandished in public, and would be worried about anyone doing such a thing.

Re: UK man imprisoned for 4 months after walking up to cops with 6" Master Sword

#22

That thing looks less dangerous than a decent pen. Def less risky than a rock. Four months in prison for this seems like abuse. This could result in lost job, lost housing, etc, for a toy. Why do people support this?

https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-42749089

Knife crime isn't a joke.

Re: UK man imprisoned for 4 months after walking up to cops with 6" Master Sword

#23
post #22

That thing looks less dangerous than a decent pen. Def less risky than a rock. Four months in prison for this seems like abuse. This could result in lost job, lost housing, etc, for a toy. Why do people support this?

https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-42749089 Knife crime isn't a joke.

What if you're being stabbed by a clown?

Re: UK man imprisoned for 4 months after walking up to cops with 6" Master Sword

#25
post #15
post #7

[Facepalm/] Whatever the local knife crime rate might be, if this guy has no links to criminal activity or gangs, then I'm thinking that 4 months in His Majesty's chokey (plus a £154 fine) is really not a win for either the Crown's or public's interests. Lecture the guy for being an idiot, give him a menu of (1) 4 hours in the stocks, in public, under an "I Wuz A Moron" sign, (2) 400 hours charity work for a Zeldatho…

Did he threaten anyone ? Did he have a prior record ? Article is lite on details, but if no priors and no threats, I would say maybe a £1000 File and community service would be enough. I do not know the laws in the UK, is it illegal to carry any type of blade in public ?

You can carry a knife with a blade up to 3" as long as it's non-locking (i.e. flips open and closed like a Swiss army knife and you don't need to hold a button to close it). You can also carry much more dangerous stuff like a scythe but you need to prove you've got a good reason (like it's your trade) and I think it needs to be wrapped or covered somehow to stop some scallywag grabbing it.

Unless I'm wrong, which I likely am.

Re: UK man imprisoned for 4 months after walking up to cops with 6" Master Sword

#26

For everyone freaking out over this: It's a 6 inch metal blade, and he was walking along a public street, holding it unsheathed in front of him. He still had it out in front of him when he approached the police and they arrested him. I'd expect the same thing for any 6 inch blade being brandished in public, and would be worried about anyone doing such a thing.

Yeah, that is more or less what the police said.

> "We take a zero tolerance to bladed articles in public, and Bray has fallen afoul of this," said Sergeant Spellman of the police's Patrol Investigations Unit, "It is possible to find fidget toys that aren’t six-inch blades. It is possible not to walk down the street holding them out in front of you. With a bit more self-awareness, Bray could have avoided contact with us completely."

Re: UK man imprisoned for 4 months after walking up to cops with 6" Master Sword

#27

For everyone freaking out over this: It's a 6 inch metal blade, and he was walking along a public street, holding it unsheathed in front of him. He still had it out in front of him when he approached the police and they arrested him. I'd expect the same thing for any 6 inch blade being brandished in public, and would be worried about anyone doing such a thing.

Is it legally a blade if it isn't sharp? I'd think the biggest danger would be similar to any toy, just poking someone's eye.

Re: UK man imprisoned for 4 months after walking up to cops with 6" Master Sword

#29

For everyone freaking out over this: It's a 6 inch metal blade, and he was walking along a public street, holding it unsheathed in front of him. He still had it out in front of him when he approached the police and they arrested him. I'd expect the same thing for any 6 inch blade being brandished in public, and would be worried about anyone doing such a thing.

Is it legally a blade if it isn't sharp? I'd think the biggest danger would be similar to any toy, just poking someone's eye.

The tip is sharp enough.

But jailtime is too much for being just stupid.

Re: UK man imprisoned for 4 months after walking up to cops with 6" Master Sword

#30
>What’s missing from every report about this I could find, and what is so crucial to understanding this story, however is that Anthony Bray is a repeat offender with a long rap sheet and numerous prison sentences, several of which were for burglary including serial burglary. In 2011, Bray was convicted and sentenced to four years in prison after getting “three strikes” for burgling residences. But his run-ins with the law go back to 1989 and he was in court numerous times throughout the 90s as well.

https://www.forbes.com/sites/erikkain/2024/07/03/zelda-maste...

Post reply on HN