Live data from Hacker News

Is anyone interested in a better Hacker News?

news.ycombinator.com

21–30 of 71 posts

Re: Is anyone interested in a better Hacker News?

#21
The single biggest problem I have is finding an article again at a later time. Even if one remembers the item or list number at the time of viewing (which I don't unless I take special note) that number will change almost immediately, a day or two later the article can be buried many pages down or have disappeared altogether.

Then there's the problem of remembering the story's title so one can search for it. Say, several days later I want to revisit a story that I remember the substance of but I have forgotten its title then sometimes it's almost impossible for me to find it again (stories often have short or cryptic titles that have little bearing with their content).

There's also a similar problem with comments, if I want to revisit a comment I read several days earlier, it's often almost impossible to find—unless I've noted the handle of the poster.

Another annoyance are stories behind firewalls, the poster will have access but many of us will not. It would make sense for these stories to be flagged with a big red dot or such so we can bypass them.

Re: Is anyone interested in a better Hacker News?

#22
post #20

Yea, no. HN is the pinnacle of UI as far as I am concerned. It is as simple as is necessary but not lacking in features. And the filtering/ranking of articles is top-notch. The only thing I miss, content wise, is political posts, because I enjoyed the discussions around here. I dislike that (almost) all politics-centric articles are effectively assigned to oblivion immediately.

Except for the "Sorry, we're not able to serve your requests this quickly." like 13 times a day.

Re: Is anyone interested in a better Hacker News?

#24
No, I come here in part for the content, but more specifically because I really enjoy the content centric approach the site has. Information is very easy to parse. Without examples, I imagine when you say 'better user exp.' you mean the same kind of enshitification that reddit has gone down.

If you compare old.reddit.com to www.reddit.com you'll see what I mean. Reddit used to look and behave a lot like HN, and that is what made it a prime source of information. Currently, it surives off it's userbase but it is no longer a good primary source of information because unit time vs unit information is quite poor now.

Re: Is anyone interested in a better Hacker News?

#26
I think many here could take the same model (users, posts, comments etc) and make something more rich in the browser. But you cant just trivially have the user base that HN has by doing so.

Since people are mentioning their gripes: Mine is titles are black but once clicked they become the same grey color as the line below each post title, which is also a link for the commments, the point count etc. So if you click on a title, read, then press back it becomes hard to distinquish or find a previously clicked link esp when the order of post changes.

In short, visited title links should be a different color

Re: Is anyone interested in a better Hacker News?

#27
post #13

HN's UI is not the product.

For me it is. The reason HN wins out over a curated set of subreddits for me is the fact that the UI is no bullshit. It is plain, simple, and does what is required to quickly and effectively communication information and not a thing more.

Re: Is anyone interested in a better Hacker News?

#28

The single biggest problem I have is finding an article again at a later time. Even if one remembers the item or list number at the time of viewing (which I don't unless I take special note) that number will change almost immediately, a day or two later the article can be buried many pages down or have disappeared altogether. Then there's the problem of remembering the story's title so one can search for it. Say, sev…

> I have is finding an article again at a later time. Even if one remembers the item or list number at the time of viewing (which I don't unless I take special note) that number will change almost immediately

There is a button below every post labelled ‘favourite’, once you’ve marked a post as favourite you can access the list of such bookmarked posts under your profile settings called favourited posts

Here’s a link to your one : https://news.ycombinator.com/favorites?id=hilbert42

> Then there's the problem of remembering the story's title so one can search for it. > There's also a similar problem with comments.

There’s tool at https://hn.algolia.com to help you search for posts via both title and comments

> There's also a similar problem with comments, if I want to revisit a comment I read several days earlier, it's often almost impossible to find—unless I've noted the handle of the poster.

You can quickly search for all comments on hn.algolia.com

Its a YC 2014 batch company.

Re: Is anyone interested in a better Hacker News?

#30

The single biggest problem I have is finding an article again at a later time. Even if one remembers the item or list number at the time of viewing (which I don't unless I take special note) that number will change almost immediately, a day or two later the article can be buried many pages down or have disappeared altogether. Then there's the problem of remembering the story's title so one can search for it. Say, sev…

Yeah I don't like disappearing articles. I've missed some very interesting articles only to stumble upon them by chance in https://hn.algolia.com

A quick tip though which helped me: you can favorite posts and comments. You need to open each to see the favorite link.

Post reply on HN