Live data from Hacker News

Mitch McConnell: We Cannot Repeat the Mistakes of the 1930s

nytimes.com

21–25 of 25 posts

Re: Mitch McConnell: We Cannot Repeat the Mistakes of the 1930s

#21
post #11
post #8

> Some vocal corners of the American right are trying to resurrect the discredited brand of prewar isolationism and deny the basic value of the alliance system that has kept the postwar peace. By “some on the right “ you mean your presidential candidate and most of your party.

Not to mention most liberals until five minutes ago. If you had told me twenty years ago that supposed democrats were agreeing with Mitch McConnell and acting out Team America World Police, I wouldn’t have believed you. https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0372588/ .

> Not to mention most liberals until five minutes ago.

Some fringe leftists are isolationists, to be sure. Liberals? No.

Re: Mitch McConnell: We Cannot Repeat the Mistakes of the 1930s

#22
post #21
post #11

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Not to mention most liberals until five minutes ago. If you had told me twenty years ago that supposed democrats were agreeing with Mitch McConnell and acting out Team America World Police, I wouldn’t have believed you. https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0372588/ .

> Not to mention most liberals until five minutes ago. Some fringe leftists are isolationists, to be sure. Liberals? No.

The mainstream liberal position back when I was a Democrat is that America’s policing of the world was a bad thing. The movie “Team America: World Police” reflected the sentiment of Jon Stewart watching younger Democrats. Stanning for NATO and “our allies” was for evil neocons like Bush and Cheney.

Re: Mitch McConnell: We Cannot Repeat the Mistakes of the 1930s

#23
post #22
post #21

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Not to mention most liberals until five minutes ago. Some fringe leftists are isolationists, to be sure. Liberals? No.

The mainstream liberal position back when I was a Democrat is that America’s policing of the world was a bad thing. The movie “Team America: World Police” reflected the sentiment of Jon Stewart watching younger Democrats. Stanning for NATO and “our allies” was for evil neocons like Bush and Cheney.

"policing of the world" is already politically fraught. The classic leftist argument is that America entered unjust foreign wars for political points / foreign resources / dick waving.

Re: Mitch McConnell: We Cannot Repeat the Mistakes of the 1930s

#24
post #23
post #22

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The mainstream liberal position back when I was a Democrat is that America’s policing of the world was a bad thing. The movie “Team America: World Police” reflected the sentiment of Jon Stewart watching younger Democrats. Stanning for NATO and “our allies” was for evil neocons like Bush and Cheney.

"policing of the world" is already politically fraught. The classic leftist argument is that America entered unjust foreign wars for political points / foreign resources / dick waving.

Leftists don’t think we entered Vietnam or Korea for resources. And when I was a mainstream young liberal in the 1990s and early oughts, the complaint was about why we have “military bases around the world.” That wasn’t because we thought those were for extracting resources.

Re: Mitch McConnell: We Cannot Repeat the Mistakes of the 1930s

#25
post #24
post #23

Earlier quoted context omitted.

"policing of the world" is already politically fraught. The classic leftist argument is that America entered unjust foreign wars for political points / foreign resources / dick waving.

Leftists don’t think we entered Vietnam or Korea for resources. And when I was a mainstream young liberal in the 1990s and early oughts, the complaint was about why we have “military bases around the world.” That wasn’t because we thought those were for extracting resources.

> Leftists don’t think we entered Vietnam or Korea for resources.

Disagree, again: Back in the day, many leftists — especially the radical ones, who not infrequently were Communists or sympathizers — proclaimed loudly that Pax Americana and its small wars were facets of an allegedly-rapacious capitalist-colonialist imperialism, extracting resources from the poor and redistributing them upward to the wealthy, and suppressing popular revolutionary movements that professed to want to even things out.

(I recently re-read David Halberstam's magisterial The Best and the Brightest about the origins of U.S. involvement in Vietnam, including backing the French efforts to stay as the colonial power after liberation from Japanese occupation. Highly recommended.)

> And when I was a mainstream young liberal in the 1990s and early oughts

It's not your fault you missed the 1960s and 70s.

Post reply on HN