Live data from Hacker News

Making housing more affordable means your home's value will have to come down

theglobeandmail.com

21–30 of 192 posts

Re: Making housing more affordable means your home's value will have to come down

#21

Why do new homes have to be built in competition with existing homes? With remote work and the digital elite moving wherever, why not just pop up new developments wholesale, complete with shopping and services somewhere out of the way and cheap?

That's how we get urban sprawl in the first place, and it is not a working strategy in the long run.

Cities benefit from high urban density, and reducing density means less benefit.

Re: Making housing more affordable means your home's value will have to come down

#22

Well, I'm against affordable housing then. Let Blackrock, who bought over 40% of the single family homes on the market, take it on the chin. Perhaps we can do a fire sale of corporate-owned homes. This has made me determined to fight affordable housing even more so. I'd also like to ask, why is British journalism so shit tier? It's a fucking joke.

It is simply impossible to reduce cost of homes without reducing the money you would sell your home for, those are the same thing.

Re: Making housing more affordable means your home's value will have to come down

#23

It’s going to be very difficult to make housing more affordable with high interest rates and high inflation. I highly doubt just increasing supply is going to be enough.

Make a law that only humans can buy residential property, and only one house for one human.

Re: Making housing more affordable means your home's value will have to come down

#24
> To raise housing affordability, we have to lower prices, or at least get price increases consistently below the rate of inflation.

I'll pick door number two, Monty. Not because that's what I actually want, but because I'm pretty certain that's how it will play out.

Lowering nominal asset prices is almost as hard as lowering nominal wages. It only happens when policymakers screw up.

That's what inflation is for.

Re: Making housing more affordable means your home's value will have to come down

#25
post #18

This is so fundamental to the issue. It is impossible for housing to be simultaneously a good investment and affordable. Policymakers simply have to decide if they cater to those that already own homes, or those desperately wanting to buy one. I feel strongly housing is a basic human right, and so we should stop viewing residential property as an appreciating asset.

Housing can be an asset and a basic right. The rights based housing just isn't in the center of a capital city. Also, do you mean housing ownership, or just housing? People can be housed in houses they don't own too - and it's probably better if it's owned by the municipality.

Re: Making housing more affordable means your home's value will have to come down

#26

It’s going to be very difficult to make housing more affordable with high interest rates and high inflation. I highly doubt just increasing supply is going to be enough.

Investment banks will just buy up any affordable housing.

The moment the federal government (Federal Reserve), private equity and investment firms like BlackRock started buying up every available home not nailed down it was the beginning of the end for the US consumer.

Re: Making housing more affordable means your home's value will have to come down

#27
It seems like the author is willfully miss-understanding Trudeau's statement.

Value and affordability can be considered independently.

Increasing median income and economic growth both increase affordability, even if housing costs track inflation.

Re: Making housing more affordable means your home's value will have to come down

#28

I really don't give a shit about the financial value of my home to someone else. Sure, my mortgage is calculated on it and I'll be paying that for the rest of my life but the true "value" of my home is the quality of life my family and I can enjoy here. What you're talking about is how much money some investor can make off of the desire of people to have this quality of life value for themselves. And quite honestly i…

The only reason I care about the value of my house is to know what I can get out of it if i need to move.

If my house goes down in value but the trend is roughly general then I don't care indeed.

Re: Making housing more affordable means your home's value will have to come down

#29

Not necessarily. If you add density to an existing lot, your land increases in value, and since it’s likely the majority of the value of your property, your property probably goes up in value. Then, the increased supply decreases the cost of shelter.

> your property probably goes up in value.

> decreases the cost of shelter.

Which is it?

Re: Making housing more affordable means your home's value will have to come down

#30
As a homeowner I see little benefit for me for the insane value of my home. Do I want to pay more in property taxes? No. If I sell it’s to just buy a different insanely priced home. I suppose I’m privileged in that I have other retirement plans so my kids will inherit my home - and that’s good I guess if they ever want to afford a home. Homes being an investment is the wrong mindset for a healthy society. Have cheap homes so you have enough money to invest in something else. I couldn’t care less if the value of my home plummets if all other desirable homes did too. Heck, I’d celebrate it. Seems to me the people who care are those who invest in real estate instead of just want a nice place to live.
Post reply on HN