Live data from Hacker News

Google releases smart watch for kids

store.google.com

21–30 of 809 posts

Re: Google releases smart watch for kids

#21
post #8

There's no mention of software support lifetime. If this is just another multi-hundred dollar electronic gadget that's going to be useless in 2 years, why would I buy it for my kid? I can get a refurb Apple Watch SE 2nd gen direct from Apple for $209. I'm clearly not going to buy this Google watch because of the price.

If the child doesn't carry a phone you'd need a cellular Apple Watch for $250 which is slightly more but probably worth it for the software support.

Re: Google releases smart watch for kids

#22
post #8

There's no mention of software support lifetime. If this is just another multi-hundred dollar electronic gadget that's going to be useless in 2 years, why would I buy it for my kid? I can get a refurb Apple Watch SE 2nd gen direct from Apple for $209. I'm clearly not going to buy this Google watch because of the price.

> going to be useless in 2 years, why would I buy it for my kid

Don't worry about it. I will be broken or lost far before those 2 years :)

Re: Google releases smart watch for kids

#24
> Fitbit Ace LTE is designed to protect your child’s privacy and wellbeing. Parents can see their child’s recent activity and goal progress, but older data will be automatically deleted from our systems. Location data is only shown to parents and is automatically deleted after a short time.

> There are no third-party apps or ads shown to kids, and health and wellness data will not be used for Google ads.

Sounds better than the regular smart watches.

Re: Google releases smart watch for kids

#25
post #18

Anyone else who would be uncomfortable opting your child into location, behavior and health surveillance by the world's largest advertising company?

Apple Watch exists if that's what you want.

Does Apple have a children's version of their smartwatch? I was not aware of that.

Re: Google releases smart watch for kids

#26
post #3

Smartwatches may be an overlooked answer to the kid phone conundrum. Watches have the communication and location tracking that parents demand without the distraction of phones.

100%. My kid is not getting a smartphone until he's ~16 but we're looking at a restricted smart watch right now (a flip phone would also be acceptable but a watch is physically attached which is ideal for 7 year old).

Not getting a phone you know about!

Re: Google releases smart watch for kids

#27
post #3

Smartwatches may be an overlooked answer to the kid phone conundrum. Watches have the communication and location tracking that parents demand without the distraction of phones.

100%. My kid is not getting a smartphone until he's ~16 but we're looking at a restricted smart watch right now (a flip phone would also be acceptable but a watch is physically attached which is ideal for 7 year old).

I think the issue at hand is yes you can enforce this at the family level. However unless high maturity / self awareness the kid will struggle if his peers all have phones.

This needs to be a campaign pushed at the school or even county level.

Re: Google releases smart watch for kids

#29
post #18

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Apple Watch exists if that's what you want.

Does Apple have a children's version of their smartwatch? I was not aware of that.

No, but there are several settings you can enable to make them more kid-friendly (including app limits and school hours)

Re: Google releases smart watch for kids

#30
post #18

Anyone else who would be uncomfortable opting your child into location, behavior and health surveillance by the world's largest advertising company?

Apple Watch exists if that's what you want.

That isn't really much better, except that Apples ad network is smaller than googles perhaps?
Post reply on HN