Live data from Hacker News

Twitter is now attention roulette and ultimately meaningless

playpermissionless.substack.com

21–30 of 132 posts

Re: Twitter is now attention roulette and ultimately meaningless

#21
post #20

Good timing... I'm building an alternative to Twitter and nearing our launch date. It's focused on devs and HN readers, even having an integration with HN.

Curious, what do you think can be done better? Maybe Twitter's whole approach is just not interesting anymore.

Re: Twitter is now attention roulette and ultimately meaningless

#22
post #19
post #14

This is the reason I really like Mastodon. No algorithm, just timesorted posts by who you follow.

That's exactly what Twitter does if you use the "Following" tab instead of the other one.

Yea, the article seems to not understand that there's a tab to make it to what he wants. Weird.

Re: Twitter is now attention roulette and ultimately meaningless

#24
post #14

This is the reason I really like Mastodon. No algorithm, just timesorted posts by who you follow.

I love that it’s easier to close as well! If I see stuff I’ve already seen it gives a natural stopping point.

It’s also great for engagement from the right audience. Posts on Twitter now get little to no response, whereas the same on Mastodon results in more followers and more actively engaged humans (also way nicer). Interestingly TikTok is really good for this, but you do have to bend the content to fit a shorter attention span.

Re: Twitter is now attention roulette and ultimately meaningless

#25
post #20

Good timing... I'm building an alternative to Twitter and nearing our launch date. It's focused on devs and HN readers, even having an integration with HN.

That seems ill advised. The critique of modern twitter is overblown, as can be seen when going to Threads which is even more outrage fueled than even twitter.

Re: Twitter is now attention roulette and ultimately meaningless

#26
post #23

Don't use the algorithm. Press the "following" tab.

The author is also looking to get readership, so the correct, but basically impossible, advice is:

Make sure that the vast majority of your potential readership are actively avoiding the default experience being heavily promoted by the platform.

Re: Twitter is now attention roulette and ultimately meaningless

#27
post #14

This is the reason I really like Mastodon. No algorithm, just timesorted posts by who you follow.

This limits how many people you can follow. You can't follow people who occasionally post a banger but also post a lot of stuff you don't care about.

I don't think algorithms are the issue but the intent of the algorithm is where it falls apart for most social media. It's not to cater to what you want to see but to what will keep you watching.

Mastodon missing a feature to somewhat curate your timeline automatically is what stops it from wide adoption.

Re: Twitter is now attention roulette and ultimately meaningless

#28
> Attention on Twitter no longer has any ripple effects beyond the platform

out of the internet, back into many many sub-nets all isolated and in many cases fighting each other

> Attention on Twitter no longer has any ripple effects beyond the platform

because you're now expected to pay for that, pay google, pay face book, the more of them you pay the higher your reach. money has reasserted itself as social control over the internet too; wanna be famous/go viral? pay up

Re: Twitter is now attention roulette and ultimately meaningless

#29
post #6

"Now"? Limiting outbound reach was, insanely, a deliberate decision by the new mismanagement.

Limiting outbound reach was a necessity when (a) the content itself becomes valuable for training AI and (b) you want to monetize the API.
Post reply on HN