Hacker News Board Hacker News, browsed like a classic message board
Live data from Hacker News

Metabolism of autism reveals developmental origins

medicalxpress.com

Post reply on HN
Print view View original

21–30 of 358 posts

Re: Metabolism of autism reveals developmental origins

#21

Post by somenameforme »

furyofantares wrote: post #7
faeriechangling wrote: post #2

> The researchers discovered that a small number of biochemical pathways are responsible for the majority of these changes, which could help inform new early detection and prevention strategies for autism. It won’t. Autism is a socioculturally bound diagnosis, not a single disease that exists in biology. It’s a label for those perceived by others in a certain light, defined in such a way that two with the same label…

> defined in such a way that two with the same label can have remarkably little overlap in terms of observed behaviour I believed this until my daughter was diagnosed and then I was later diagnosed. My experience with (some) professionals was a surprise to me; a much wider variety of "observed behaviors" than I expected seem to stem from sensory issues for example. And I think it makes sense that humans might adopt a…

Here [1] is the DSM diagnostic criteria for autism. It's broad to the point of absurdity. The reason many people think autism is a faux disorder is because it includes everything from an individual who simply sits in the corner endlessly flapping his hands, completely unable to function as a human being, to Bill Gates or Elon Musk. The weaker diagnoses, which is an increasingly large chunk of all of them, often seem like an effect to pathologize normal behavioral differences within people. This is, IMO, one of those things people are definitely going to look back at think 'wtf were they even thinking?'

[1] - https://a4.org.au/dsm5-asd

Re: Metabolism of autism reveals developmental origins

#23

Post by normaler »

giantg2 wrote: post #14
Der_Einzige wrote: post #12

Earlier quoted context omitted.

People with high functioning autism make up a majority of the “people who died at 25 and didn’t know it until they were 80” crowd.

I'm not sure I understand the quote.

There is an increased comorbidity with neuro divergence and harmful behaviour.

Re: Metabolism of autism reveals developmental origins

#24

Post by flatline »

faeriechangling wrote: post #10
furyofantares wrote: post #7

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> defined in such a way that two with the same label can have remarkably little overlap in terms of observed behaviour I believed this until my daughter was diagnosed and then I was later diagnosed. My experience with (some) professionals was a surprise to me; a much wider variety of "observed behaviors" than I expected seem to stem from sensory issues for example. And I think it makes sense that humans might adopt a…

If you ask the majority of people if somebody who they do not perceive as engaging in autisitic behaviours, and was not diagnosed as autistic, but considers themselves autistic, is autistic, they will say no. Scientifically (which how it’s defined in the OP), it’s not defined by psychiatrist appraisal and self-assessment plays no necessary role in the process and alone holds no diagnostic validity. We can also invert…

I’m not sure what point you are making with this reply. I’m late/adult self-identifying autistic. I’ve done this with some of the standard tests that psychiatrists use, attended workgroups related to the topic, and studied extensively. Self-diagnosis is highly accurate for autism, both for positive and negative evaluations.

I am also pursuing a formal diagnosis because so many people downplay it when I tell them I’m autistic. I don’t have the affect at first glance, but it does come out in my behaviors if you get to know me a bit. I’ve also had the luxury of therapy, eduction, etc.

I also agree that the categorization is overly broad and your original post resonates. There are various non-overlapping clusters of traits that fall under autism.

I do think, however, that at the core of it is a common difference in information and sensory processing.

Re: Metabolism of autism reveals developmental origins

#25

Post by [deleted] »

faeriechangling wrote: post #2

> The researchers discovered that a small number of biochemical pathways are responsible for the majority of these changes, which could help inform new early detection and prevention strategies for autism. It won’t. Autism is a socioculturally bound diagnosis, not a single disease that exists in biology. It’s a label for those perceived by others in a certain light, defined in such a way that two with the same label…

[deleted]

Re: Metabolism of autism reveals developmental origins

#26

Post by whimsicalism »

somenameforme wrote: post #21
furyofantares wrote: post #7

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> defined in such a way that two with the same label can have remarkably little overlap in terms of observed behaviour I believed this until my daughter was diagnosed and then I was later diagnosed. My experience with (some) professionals was a surprise to me; a much wider variety of "observed behaviors" than I expected seem to stem from sensory issues for example. And I think it makes sense that humans might adopt a…

Here [1] is the DSM diagnostic criteria for autism. It's broad to the point of absurdity. The reason many people think autism is a faux disorder is because it includes everything from an individual who simply sits in the corner endlessly flapping his hands, completely unable to function as a human being, to Bill Gates or Elon Musk. The weaker diagnoses, which is an increasingly large chunk of all of them, often seem…

frankly, this will continue as long as performance-enhancing drugs and accommodations are gated behind diagnoses

Re: Metabolism of autism reveals developmental origins

#27

Post by neom »

furyofantares wrote: post #7
faeriechangling wrote: post #2

> The researchers discovered that a small number of biochemical pathways are responsible for the majority of these changes, which could help inform new early detection and prevention strategies for autism. It won’t. Autism is a socioculturally bound diagnosis, not a single disease that exists in biology. It’s a label for those perceived by others in a certain light, defined in such a way that two with the same label…

> defined in such a way that two with the same label can have remarkably little overlap in terms of observed behaviour I believed this until my daughter was diagnosed and then I was later diagnosed. My experience with (some) professionals was a surprise to me; a much wider variety of "observed behaviors" than I expected seem to stem from sensory issues for example. And I think it makes sense that humans might adopt a…

I mean I was diagnosed with a salad of things. And then different doctors tell me different things about how they're all related or unrelated. It was honestly a very amusing situation. The only sense I got out of the whole long ass process was: neurological sensory difference "combo" in the roll of the dice, some of it given hereditarily, some this that and the other. I really see why this stuff is so frustrating for people. I'm super lucky circumstances are such for me that I can give less shits about the social issues my autism causes, allowing me to explore it.I actually just started a blog last week to share as I explore this stuff, I'm a bit shy to share it as I've never blogged in earnest before, so I have no sense of if this is good, bad, silly, lame, boring, etc: https://b.h4x.zip/autism-thinking-and-whiteboards/

Re: Metabolism of autism reveals developmental origins

#29

Post by 2four2 »

faeriechangling wrote: post #2

> The researchers discovered that a small number of biochemical pathways are responsible for the majority of these changes, which could help inform new early detection and prevention strategies for autism. It won’t. Autism is a socioculturally bound diagnosis, not a single disease that exists in biology. It’s a label for those perceived by others in a certain light, defined in such a way that two with the same label…

I think most people understand that disease nomenclature changes rapidly. Even if the word "autism" is deprecated in the future and replaced by a litany of other terms for conditions, the research is still useful and interesting.
Post reply on HN