Live data from Hacker News

Depression Rates by Country 2024

worldpopulationreview.com

21–30 of 42 posts

Re: Depression Rates by Country 2024

#21

> "While the numbers listed above (and below) are valuable and vital, it is important to keep in mind that the true rates are likely much higher, especially in less developed countries. Depression is much more likely to be diagnosed in highly developed countries, whose more robust health care infrastructures are far better equipped to identify and treat mental illnesses." This is an important quote from the article,…

I understand but reject their presumption.

Re: Depression Rates by Country 2024

#22

> "While the numbers listed above (and below) are valuable and vital, it is important to keep in mind that the true rates are likely much higher, especially in less developed countries. Depression is much more likely to be diagnosed in highly developed countries, whose more robust health care infrastructures are far better equipped to identify and treat mental illnesses." This is an important quote from the article,…

I understand but reject their presumption.

Ok but why?

Re: Depression Rates by Country 2024

#23
In my experience depression is in most cases basically a variant of burnout.

When people get stuck in a routine (job, city, hobby, political view, whatever) where they're focused mainly on the outcome rather than the process. Extreme long term thinking.

Alienation, that sort of thing.

It's common to say it's "under diagnosed" in places where people live more natural lives but I think this is correlation rather than causation.

Re: Depression Rates by Country 2024

#24

> "While the numbers listed above (and below) are valuable and vital, it is important to keep in mind that the true rates are likely much higher, especially in less developed countries. Depression is much more likely to be diagnosed in highly developed countries, whose more robust health care infrastructures are far better equipped to identify and treat mental illnesses." This is an important quote from the article,…

I understand but reject their presumption.

Do you think that depression is more likely to be diagnosed in developing nations? There’s a number of presumptions here, not sure which you disagree with specifically.

Re: Depression Rates by Country 2024

#26
post #16

One surprise in these numbers is that Africa seems to be doing better than Latin America when I would have expected them to be close to each other given the economic difficulties, violence and lack of perspective for large swaths of the population.

Often times what is understood by first-worlders as "depression" is a cluster of problems that uniquely affect decently well-off people who have been spiritually and physically subjugated by an spiritually blank industrial bureaucracy. If you measure stress, hunger, sorrow, fear, scarcity, etc. you'll find higher levels among the global poor, but if you measure "malaise, sadness, lack of purpose, emptiness, yearning…

That's correct. Humanity achieved astonishing results in technological and medical advances. But at the same time, humans still struggle with happiness.

Re: Depression Rates by Country 2024

#27

> "While the numbers listed above (and below) are valuable and vital, it is important to keep in mind that the true rates are likely much higher, especially in less developed countries. Depression is much more likely to be diagnosed in highly developed countries, whose more robust health care infrastructures are far better equipped to identify and treat mental illnesses." This is an important quote from the article,…

[deleted]

Re: Depression Rates by Country 2024

#28
Man I feel for Ukraine, our problems are trivial in comparison. They are fighting for their existence. Hard to imagine the amount of trauma the population and military are suffering from on top of just the normal bullshit that gets to us all.

Re: Depression Rates by Country 2024

#29
post #18
post #5

Earlier quoted context omitted.

https://old.reddit.com/r/MapPorn/comments/1bmna2e/fertility_... Or to quote Bertrand Russle: > There were once upon a time two sausage machines, exquisitely constructed for the purpose of turning pig into the most delicious sausages. One of these retained his zest for pig and produced sausages innumerable; the other said: 'What is pig to me? My own works are far more interesting and wonderful than any pig.' He refuse…

This is essentially just (an extremely elegant) rephrasing of Marx's theory of alienation

Both seem like something you’d say if self-reflection hurts your puzzler. Not the first folks to cast inabilities as virtues.

Re: Depression Rates by Country 2024

#30

One surprise in these numbers is that Africa seems to be doing better than Latin America when I would have expected them to be close to each other given the economic difficulties, violence and lack of perspective for large swaths of the population.

>> I would have expected them to be close to each other given the economic difficulties, violence and lack of perspective What's wrong with violence? I never found violence to be depressing. For me it was sort of the opposite as a young man.

If you can't work or progress in life due to the risk of violence (any work you do and anything you make will be stolen by those perpetrating violence) why would you even bother doing anything?
Post reply on HN