Live data from Hacker News

Google One VPN will be discontinued

9to5google.com

21–30 of 31 posts

Re: Google One VPN will be discontinued

#22
I wonder what their marketing is thinking about this. Google One is effectively just Google Drive storage with some feature add-ons. Until now, that VPN was their only 'additional' thing in the package. Without the VPN it's just a few enhancements to existing products that aren't compelling enough.

Re: Google One VPN will be discontinued

#23
I think it's 50/50 whether or not I believe the reasoning.

One one hand: killing a product for not being multi billion user multi billion dollar overnight success is incredibly on brand.

On the other hand: I 100% believe that they just found government pushback too burdensome to comply with. That would match what I saw when I worked there.

Re: Google One VPN will be discontinued

#24
I somewhat anticipated the discontinuation of Google VPN because Google didn't address the issue of DNS hijacking, particularly on their Windows client. Ironically, this unresolved issue is why I stopped using their service.

[0]: https://github.com/google/vpn-libraries/issues/36

Re: Google One VPN will be discontinued

#25

Not shocking. Their VPN app sucked ass. A) it randomly disconnected several times a day, and B) it had no "kill switch" option which would block all traffic when the VPN went down. So my connection was frequently unprotected throughout the day.

Yeah, their client was pretty bad, especially on macOS where it would sometimes get borked in a way that needed a full OS reboot to start working again.

Re: Google One VPN will be discontinued

#26
post #16

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The other explanation I’ve seen is that the 20% time leads to lots of small products without much of an overarching biz strategy

20% time was also killed by Google (even if not officially)

Yeah it’s effectively dead. Also referred to as 120% time.

Re: Google One VPN will be discontinued

#28

Not shocking. Their VPN app sucked ass. A) it randomly disconnected several times a day, and B) it had no "kill switch" option which would block all traffic when the VPN went down. So my connection was frequently unprotected throughout the day.

I can’t remember, but didn’t it require the Android Google One app to do VPN on Chromebooks? I remember it being hard to setup, but perhaps I’m misremembering my journey through dodgy VPN clients.

Re: Google One VPN will be discontinued

#29

Not shocking. Their VPN app sucked ass. A) it randomly disconnected several times a day, and B) it had no "kill switch" option which would block all traffic when the VPN went down. So my connection was frequently unprotected throughout the day.

on android there is a Killswitch.

Re: Google One VPN will be discontinued

#30

I don’t know if it’s just bad management or they want to stay out any possible antitrust case. Because with their weight Google could easily make this a multi million “small” business. Either way, it’s good they leave some for the next guy to earn. ( not because the goodness of their heart I’m sure )

One billion+ users is the size of market that Google is interested in
Post reply on HN