Live data from Hacker News

Sora could ruin peoples lives

community.openai.com

21–30 of 185 posts

Re: Sora could ruin peoples lives

#21

Every time Sam Altman announces some new offering at OpenAI, I get a little more thankful I don't have any children.

A child's life is valuable each moment. There's no guarantee of security and safety for any human anywhere at any time. We can't just be paralyzed by possible negative outcomes, life requires taking risks.

(You might not want kids for some other reason, like free time, don't like kids, etc, but if you would otherwise have kids except for the dangers in the world, I'd say rethink your risk tolerance)

Re: Sora could ruin peoples lives

#22
I'm not a fan of this sort of takes. History has shown time and time again that pretty much any technological innovation is a net good, despite the protests of the luddites. Progressive creatives see this type of tech as a tool to simplify and re-adapt their process.

The post author is 16, and an aspiring animator. If their attitude is to be scared of tech, instead of being insanely curious about it, they are not on the right path to become a creative, regardless of AI.

Re: Sora could ruin peoples lives

#23
The impact of technology like Sora on people who work in the animation and firm industry is indeed troubling. In my ideal world it leads to an explosion of creativity as people with great skill and taste use it to produce even more ambitious work - but the negative world in which those skills become undervalued and we get way more content of a much lower quality is certainly possible.

Something that worries me more at the moment is the impact this will have on people's plans.

In this post we have a 16 year old who's passionate about animation but is questioning whether it's a viable industry to join.

I've seen plenty of examples of students who planned to be computer programmers but are now having second thoughts about that career as well.

Twenty years ago there was a similar fear in programming, that all of the jobs were going to be outsourced to lower cost countries. I believe there were people who changed their career plans as a result of that fear back then as well.

I hope we don't see a huge flurry of people making life altering career decisions based on their fear of AI which they later come to regret as this shakes out in a more positive direction.

(I also hope we don't see people who genuinely DO regret their career decisions if AI turns out to have the negative impact that many people fear today.)

Re: Sora could ruin peoples lives

#24

The first response to the original post is quite possibly one of the most tone-deaf and unempathetic things I've ever read.

As tone deaf as if… it was written by a machine? This will be increasingly more difficult to tell as time goes on.

Re: Sora could ruin peoples lives

#25
post #17

Every time Sam Altman announces some new offering at OpenAI, I get a little more thankful I don't have any children.

The same. That, and the crazy demographic explosion in the world.

What demographic explosion? In most developed countries at least there is a baby bust. Populations are rapidly aging.

Re: Sora could ruin peoples lives

#26

Every time Sam Altman announces some new offering at OpenAI, I get a little more thankful I don't have any children.

That's such a bizarre, ahistorical take. Regardless of anything that Sam Altman does, living conditions for children in developed countries will remain far better than what most people have experienced since the origin of our species.

Re: Sora could ruin peoples lives

#28

Very good discussion there. “I am 68 years old, on the opposite spectrum of life’s journey. At your age, I had the same passion to be a writer. But when personal computers became available just a few years later, that passion changed to becoming a computer programmer. I’ve been doing that ever since. My point is: Don’t lose your passion. Learn everything you can about this new technology and figure out how to use it…

The guys who’s been a computer engineer “ever since”, ie for several decades, is using that as a reason to be passionate about what you do, completely ignoring the fact that the whole worry with AI is that it will obsolete industries within years.

Re: Sora could ruin peoples lives

#29
I think what a lot of the answers gloss over is that the period of adjustment to the new technology often does pull the rug from under people who have invested a good deal of time and attention becoming skilled at something. Our lives are of limited length therefore the concern for a generation of people is real and shouldn't be just treated as a detail of history.

Equally in many areas the end result is a loss of something (often intangible) which we accept as "good enough" and which may take a long time to be recaptured.

The steam engine may well have been a good thing in the long run but I'm sure it did tear apart the fabric of many people's lives and I think it's reasonable to commiserate.

Re: Sora could ruin peoples lives

#30

Every time Sam Altman announces some new offering at OpenAI, I get a little more thankful I don't have any children.

Because they may turn out like him?

Heh. I'm not a part of the private St. Louis preparatory school and "drop out of Stanford when a VC tells you you're Jesus Christ" set. I doubt any of my potential offspring would be either.

No, more because Altman is an even higher form of Silicon Valley creature than we've seen before. This is a segment of society that thinks that you can directly judge something's benefit to humanity based on the IPO it could have, and pretty much nothing else. They create sea changes in society knowing that it's going to be a very rough transition for people who don't have their levels of wealth to deal with the consequences.

Previously, seeing was believing. Sure, there was Photoshop and CGI, but pictures aren't as telling as video, and most people didn't have the capital necessary to cook up anything they wanted using CGI. This, though... anyone could make up anything for any reason, with dire consequences.

Just spitballing here, what if, say, political campaigns started releasing generated video of opponents in compromising positions with minors? Or videos were posted to social media designed to create a casus belli for a country?

It won't matter for the companies making those tools; their stock prices will be fine. Well, at least until the EMP is set off near the data center.

I don't want to be responsible for a human being coming up in what is essentially a 100% post-truth world.

Post reply on HN