Live data from Hacker News

Doorway effect

en.wikipedia.org

21–30 of 150 posts

Re: Doorway effect

#21

I only skimmed, but the two linked articles have ~50 participants or _fewer_ (college students) for each.

Meaning that the effect must be fairly strong to be observable in two studies with n=50?

I would agree in general, but I would like to see three or more, as well as variations to test the boundaries of this.

Things can go wrong in one or two studies, so having independent replication is needed to really cement things.

Re: Doorway effect

#22

I've noticed that retracing your steps (either literally if walking or not) helps enormously. For me it happens that I'm doing something on my phone, remember to do something else, switch apps to do it, and literally forget what it is. But by going back or checking the recent apps I find again the "trigger" of the original reminder. For example, you are checking [social network] and you see a post that reminds you to…

> I've noticed that retracing your steps (either literally if walking or not) helps enormously.

Definitely. My wife and I have a running joke about it. I'll walk into the room, she says "What's up?" and I say "trying to find something and I forgot what it was. Hold on, let me go back to my office to remember."

Re: Doorway effect

#23
My mother had this as she went senile. She would come to a complete halt in the doorways.

Then when my dog got old and doolaly he started to do it.

Not just humans

Re: Doorway effect

#24

I only skimmed, but the two linked articles have ~50 participants or _fewer_ (college students) for each.

Meaning that the effect must be fairly strong to be observable in two studies with n=50? I would agree in general, but I would like to see three or more, as well as variations to test the boundaries of this. Things can go wrong in one or two studies, so having independent replication is needed to really cement things.

> Meaning that the effect must be fairly strong to be observable in two studies with n=50?

Do what now? Isn't the problem that it could have randomly happened (especially if people did a bunch of other similar studies that didn't observe an effect, and only these two were published)?

Re: Doorway effect

#25
Living in a shotgun house has convinced me this effect is very real. When I have to walk from the front to the back, I have developed the habit of saying what I'm going to do as I walk through each of the five doors I have to pass through; this puts my intent into a different mental pipeline, that's much more resistant to being flushed out when I pass through a door.

If my husband is at home then he tends to get in on the act, leading to conversations like "I should set a timer for five minutes." "You should set a timer for five minutes!" "I'm gonna set a timer for five minutes." "Didja set that timer for five minutes?" "I just set a timer for five minutes!" when I'm crossing from the kitchen to the living room and leaving some water to boil.

Re: Doorway effect

#27
Widely known in the restaurant industry as the walk-in effect. You go into the walk-in fridge and then forget what you went in there to get. You go back to your station to remember.

Re: Doorway effect

#28
post #20

Ah, this is explains the effect of entering a room and not remembering why you went there.

... Or pressing the start key in Vista and seeing a wall of live tile distractions.

In my experience the start page idea was a software implementation of "Doorway Effect". I always had to return to the desktop to have my "refrigerator logic" spin up.

https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/fridge_logic>

Re: Doorway effect

#29
Forgetting your dreams when you wake up in morning. The doorway effect could explain that too. Bigger door = bigger/more frequent effect.

Re: Doorway effect

#30
This has some similarities to the cultural anthropological concept of ritual liminality:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Liminality

The "doorway effect" is a more everyday phenomenon. Interesting that the idea that transitions result in disorientation scales from the mundane to the religious.

Post reply on HN