Live data from Hacker News

Workers are filming their layoffs, then posting to TikTok. What could go wrong?

bbc.com

21–30 of 46 posts

Re: Workers are filming their layoffs, then posting to TikTok. What could go wrong?

#21

This young lady may or may not have destroyed her career prospects. I have no idea. But, if the outcome is that all employers need to think about whether their firings/layoffs are broadcast for everyone to see and critique, I’d say that she made the world a little bit better :)

She has definitely damaged herself professionally.

It was a very naive thing to do. I'm actually surprised that instead of laying her off they didn't just sack her, but maybe there was a delay between the meeting and her releasing it.

She got a few likes on social media though, so that's good.

Re: Workers are filming their layoffs, then posting to TikTok. What could go wrong?

#22

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Regardless of bad commentary, it’s a cogent point. Debate the idea, not the idiot.

While the risk is obvious, what is the alternative ? You can go down as a number on the spreadsheet, or you can show everyone else they are also numbers on a spreadsheet. Her behaviour is a first step towards a different workplace. The effectiveness is questionable, but what more can a single, non organized individual can do ?

Everyone else with any measure of maturity knows they're just numbers on a spreadsheet. It's not a startling revelation.

Re: Workers are filming their layoffs, then posting to TikTok. What could go wrong?

#23
> What could go wrong?

Probably nothing. Bad things happen in dark corners. Shining a little sunlight into a dark corner is almost always a good thing.

In this case, possibly a very good thing. Because even just the threat of a little sunlight being shone on your performance generally improves it. This viral TikTok video made that possibility very real in a lot of peoples minds.

So I'm guessing this video going to have an outsized impact, for the better.

Re: Workers are filming their layoffs, then posting to TikTok. What could go wrong?

#24

This young lady may or may not have destroyed her career prospects. I have no idea. But, if the outcome is that all employers need to think about whether their firings/layoffs are broadcast for everyone to see and critique, I’d say that she made the world a little bit better :)

She has definitely damaged herself professionally. It was a very naive thing to do. I'm actually surprised that instead of laying her off they didn't just sack her, but maybe there was a delay between the meeting and her releasing it. She got a few likes on social media though, so that's good.

No she hasn't. You offer no support for your claim. I'd rather hire her than you and I have been industry for over 30 years.

Re: Workers are filming their layoffs, then posting to TikTok. What could go wrong?

#25

As a millennial, why does every aspect of our life have to be so performative? People are mistaking attention seeking for "transparency". If you spend every waking of your moment on camera or making everyone around you paranoid about being on camera, no one in your life including yourself is every going to be genuine. Besides, it's a dumb thing to do. Depending on the state you or the HR person is in you could be vio…

What a poor take that projects your own biases onto the situation.

Every layoff should be recorded and she broke no laws.

Re: Workers are filming their layoffs, then posting to TikTok. What could go wrong?

#26

This young lady may or may not have destroyed her career prospects. I have no idea. But, if the outcome is that all employers need to think about whether their firings/layoffs are broadcast for everyone to see and critique, I’d say that she made the world a little bit better :)

Did she make the word a better place, or a worse one?

In my opinion, after seeing this video, any HR department will simply say “you are being laid off” and give no other information. I imagine this could only reduce the amount of information that an HR dept would give.

This is my cynical point of view, at least.

Re: Workers are filming their layoffs, then posting to TikTok. What could go wrong?

#27

This young lady may or may not have destroyed her career prospects. I have no idea. But, if the outcome is that all employers need to think about whether their firings/layoffs are broadcast for everyone to see and critique, I’d say that she made the world a little bit better :)

Did she make the word a better place, or a worse one? In my opinion, after seeing this video, any HR department will simply say “you are being laid off” and give no other information. I imagine this could only reduce the amount of information that an HR dept would give. This is my cynical point of view, at least.

Which would be fantastic and exactly what she asked for in the video. She just wanted them to drop the obvious bullshit.

Re: Workers are filming their layoffs, then posting to TikTok. What could go wrong?

#28
I had an old roommate who was the political whistle-blower for NYC police when they lied about the number of minorities they arrest. He was instrumental in getting attention to the disproportionate number of minorities adversely affected by stop and frisk. As an analyst, he had access to the actual raw data and was the one actually creating the reports internally and decided to do speak out when, despite his reporting, the police and politicians were lying to the public.

He had an incredible background on paper (went to Harvard, numerous high level and trusted analyst positions in government, high profile Twitter account). After he leaked the information and had his 15 minutes of fame, his career was basically destroyed. I watched, first hand, over the course of the next two years how he couldn't get a job in his field anymore -- or any field for that matter. After going through his savings, he was forced to take a job working part time at a used clothing store, working for an abusive boss.

Don't underestimate the power of forever getting your name indexed in Google. He was labeled as a "gadfly" by government. Watching him struggle and what it did to his mental and physical health over was absolutely heartbreaking. I really hope this woman doesn't have the same outcome, but I am not optimistic.

Re: Workers are filming their layoffs, then posting to TikTok. What could go wrong?

#29

This young lady may or may not have destroyed her career prospects. I have no idea. But, if the outcome is that all employers need to think about whether their firings/layoffs are broadcast for everyone to see and critique, I’d say that she made the world a little bit better :)

She has definitely damaged herself professionally. It was a very naive thing to do. I'm actually surprised that instead of laying her off they didn't just sack her, but maybe there was a delay between the meeting and her releasing it. She got a few likes on social media though, so that's good.

[deleted]

Re: Workers are filming their layoffs, then posting to TikTok. What could go wrong?

#30

I had an old roommate who was the political whistle-blower for NYC police when they lied about the number of minorities they arrest. He was instrumental in getting attention to the disproportionate number of minorities adversely affected by stop and frisk. As an analyst, he had access to the actual raw data and was the one actually creating the reports internally and decided to do speak out when, despite his reportin…

If your takeaway from that anecdote is "don't whistleblow" I feel like you're in a different dimension than me.

My takeaway is that he probably has a viable lawsuit and maybe pay somebody 5k for some SEO, or change his name for free.

Post reply on HN