Live data from Hacker News

Elon Musk's Latest Robot Video Accidentally Gives Away the Magic Trick

forbes.com

21–27 of 27 posts

Re: Elon Musk's Latest Robot Video Accidentally Gives Away the Magic Trick

#21
post #15

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Intuitive's Da Vinci has been doing it commercially for 20 years....in surgury

Please don't mistake progression for completion. And, I don't think comparing the two is logical, for price (Da Vinci is $2,000,000), end goal (the 500kg Da Vinci will never walk across the room and pick up a box), or even degrees of freedom.

You don't know what they're working on. If anyone can design a robot that does that, it's them, or Boston dynamics

Re: Elon Musk's Latest Robot Video Accidentally Gives Away the Magic Trick

#22
post #18

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'm sorry, what does the CyberTruck have to do with the conversation, or their fairly obvious progression in actuation, or progression in making a nice humanoid platform for machine learning use, or Da Vinci?

It means the gap between what Musk promises will be available, and the cost thereof, versus the reality of what is available, when, and for how much, is "rather sizable" at times.

I'm still not sure how Da Vinci relates, or the CyberTruck.

But, sure, I don't really pay attention to timelines, since I don't have it on pre-order. They're making great progress. They will throw ML/AI at it, and it will be interesting to see what comes out. For people that enjoy tech, this is neat.

Re: Elon Musk's Latest Robot Video Accidentally Gives Away the Magic Trick

#23
post #15

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Please don't mistake progression for completion. And, I don't think comparing the two is logical, for price (Da Vinci is $2,000,000), end goal (the 500kg Da Vinci will never walk across the room and pick up a box), or even degrees of freedom.

You don't know what they're working on. If anyone can design a robot that does that, it's them, or Boston dynamics

[deleted]

Re: Elon Musk's Latest Robot Video Accidentally Gives Away the Magic Trick

#24
post #15

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Intuitive's Da Vinci has been doing it commercially for 20 years....in surgury

Please don't mistake progression for completion. And, I don't think comparing the two is logical, for price (Da Vinci is $2,000,000), end goal (the 500kg Da Vinci will never walk across the room and pick up a box), or even degrees of freedom.

> And, I don't think comparing the two is logical, for price (Da Vinci is $2,000,000), end goal (the 500kg Da Vinci will never walk across the room and pick up a box), or even degrees of freedom.

How much does a Tesla robot cost and where can I buy one?

Re: Elon Musk's Latest Robot Video Accidentally Gives Away the Magic Trick

#25
post #15

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Please don't mistake progression for completion. And, I don't think comparing the two is logical, for price (Da Vinci is $2,000,000), end goal (the 500kg Da Vinci will never walk across the room and pick up a box), or even degrees of freedom.

> And, I don't think comparing the two is logical, for price (Da Vinci is $2,000,000) What's the over-under on the $35K CyberTruck ever making it to market, instead of vague handwaving "sometime towards the end of 2025, maybe"?

You must have missed the memo that the $35k Cybertruck is now the $60,990 Cybertruck (this is the standard-range, available in 2025 model). You will never be able to buy one new from Tesla for anywhere close to $35k, and the fact that they announced the price as $35k _and took customer money_ based on that should, IMHO, result in financial penalties and jail time for the executives involved.

Re: Elon Musk's Latest Robot Video Accidentally Gives Away the Magic Trick

#26
post #22

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It means the gap between what Musk promises will be available, and the cost thereof, versus the reality of what is available, when, and for how much, is "rather sizable" at times.

I'm still not sure how Da Vinci relates, or the CyberTruck. But, sure, I don't really pay attention to timelines, since I don't have it on pre-order. They're making great progress . They will throw ML/AI at it, and it will be interesting to see what comes out. For people that enjoy tech, this is neat.

"They're making great progress. They will throw ML/AI at it, and it will be interesting to see what comes out. For people that enjoy tech, this is neat."

-Me, hearing Elon in 2015 describing fully autonomous self-driving as a "solved problem" and stating that "we will have complete autonomy in approximately two years."

Re: Elon Musk's Latest Robot Video Accidentally Gives Away the Magic Trick

#27
post #19

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Baseline is able bodied human which Optimus is supposed to replace on manufacturing line.

Engineering doesn't ever involve starting with a final product. We're witnessing progression, nothing more nothing less. Progression can be observed and "appreciated", on its own. Working towards something "neat" is the modus operandi of most users here, and for some of us, seeing others working towards something "neat" is fun to watch.

I agree with this sentiment, and would likely 100% agree in this particular case if this were being done by some brand new startup. But at this point, Tesla's history is so littered with broken promises, truth-stretching, and outright lies that by default I treat any new announcement from them not only as marketing theater, but as a deliberate attempt to actively deceive.
Post reply on HN