With the present conslusion from climate change models on how the water will rise due to increased temperature, is not parts of the Netherlands no longer viable and people and business will have ot move to regions with higher elevation? Should such a drastic move be taking place now, before the model conclusion say it will be underwater? That based on the fact that the 1,5C goal has long since become untenable withou…
Dutch storm surge barrier closes automatically
21–28 of 28 posts
Re: Dutch storm surge barrier closes automatically
#22This seems to have been automatically translated from https://www.nu.nl/binnenland/6295147/maeslantkering-voor-het... . For example, "coupure" ( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coupure ) got translated as "denomination", which is not correct in this context :)
This is a rubbish submission from a low-effort spam website and should be replaced with the link you found.
Re: Dutch storm surge barrier closes automatically
#23The Maeslantkering closed automatically for the first time since its completion in 1998.
I find the emphasis on the automatic decision making and operation here interesting. Why does it need to be automatic? Is it to relieve political pressure on the decision- makers, since closing the barrier prevents traffic in and out of Rotterdam? Or is it because the algorithm is so complex and it has to anticipate water flow from the Rhine?
From the wiki: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maeslantkering
Re: Dutch storm surge barrier closes automatically
#24The Maeslantkering closed automatically for the first time since its completion in 1998.
It had never been necessary before?
Re: Dutch storm surge barrier closes automatically
#25With the present conslusion from climate change models on how the water will rise due to increased temperature, is not parts of the Netherlands no longer viable and people and business will have ot move to regions with higher elevation? Should such a drastic move be taking place now, before the model conclusion say it will be underwater? That based on the fact that the 1,5C goal has long since become untenable withou…
What might become a problem though, is flooding of rivers. The Netherlands is a river delta for a large part of Europe. Melting snow in other countries gets transported to the North Sea by several large rivers. If (when) sea level rises it gets harder to get rid of al that water fast enough. Perhaps we have to dam up rivers until low tide and let it all out at once, for example.
Still, we are on top of it and there is still enough time to build higher dams and dikes. We'll survive.
Re: Dutch storm surge barrier closes automatically
#26The Maeslantkering closed automatically for the first time since its completion in 1998.
- It was completed in 1997.
- It automatically closed in 2018, but the algorithm was adjusted to close at a lower water level, specifically to enforce a closing under storm conditions.
source: https://www.rijkswaterstaat.nl/water/waterbeheer/bescherming...
(that is the Dutch agency responsible for the barrier)
Re: Dutch storm surge barrier closes automatically
#27With the present conslusion from climate change models on how the water will rise due to increased temperature, is not parts of the Netherlands no longer viable and people and business will have ot move to regions with higher elevation? Should such a drastic move be taking place now, before the model conclusion say it will be underwater? That based on the fact that the 1,5C goal has long since become untenable withou…
The automated barrier closure was triggered by the combination of a winter storm and high tide pushing in a lot of extra water up the river. Add to that saturated rivers draining essentially most of Europe's rainfall and you get a picture of what is routinely dealt with there. The rivers are actually a bigger issue than the sea. Forested areas that used to absorb a lot of water are vastly reduced in size. More extreme rainfall now flows straight into the Rhine and Meusse rivers, which both exit where this barrier is. The solution for this is not more dikes but flood zones.
Other parts of the world are much less ready for higher water levels. Florida for example is particularly poorly prepared for even modest water level rises and has much less extreme tides; so the averages matter more. There just isn't a whole lot in terms of sea defenses and other infrastructure. Any storm is likely to push a lot of water in. Combined with even modest sea level rises that means there just is a lot of property at risk.
Re: Dutch storm surge barrier closes automatically
#28The intesting part: The flood defense closes automatically at a water level of 3 meters above NAP (Amsterdam water level baseline) at Rotterdam or 2.9 meters above NAP at Dordrecht. The two doors, each 210 meters wide and 22 meters high, fill with water when the barrier closes. They then sink to the bottom in about two hours. A computer system automatically determines whether the barrier should be closed. However, a…