Live data from Hacker News

Google+ gets a redesign

googleblog.blogspot.com

21–30 of 193 posts

Re: Google+ gets a redesign

#21

Wow, huge improvement! Is the cover photo new too? (I haven't checked out G+ in a while.. - copied from FB?!) Looks more "fun" in any case, which is good. (Not saying they have to go completely spastic but this is a good mix)

As far as I know, Path had done the cover photo thing before Facebook.

Re: Google+ gets a redesign

#24

Wow, huge improvement! Is the cover photo new too? (I haven't checked out G+ in a while.. - copied from FB?!) Looks more "fun" in any case, which is good. (Not saying they have to go completely spastic but this is a good mix)

As far as I know, Path had done the cover photo thing before Facebook.

What's the "cover photo thing"?

Re: Google+ gets a redesign

#26
post #19
post #9

Yeah I really like this, and I also like how google is not giving up. I do think it has potential, and if google can hit it, it will be huge for the company. I think the piece that's missing is integration from other third party services - I would use my google+ account a lot more if I could post to it from apps I use often like twitter, instagram etc. There's always share to twitter in almost every app, which makes…

One of the most hotly discussed API feature requests [1] but I'm nervous about it. I don't want my stream filled with junk the way my Facebook stream is. [1] http://code.google.com/p/google-plus-platform/issues/detail?...

> I don't want my stream filled with junk the way my Facebook stream is.

I always wondered why the Google+ team didn't implement that from the get go but after reading that, that's probably the biggest reason as to why they haven't.

Re: Google+ gets a redesign

#27
post #7
post #4

I genuinely think Google+ has plenty of potential. Google's strategy seems a little more unified in terms of the way the posts are linking to search results, how you can setup circles and the other more niftier features that have been added that Facebook has yet to add. But despite all of that. Something is missing, and i just cant quite put my finger on it.

People. It's missing people.

Soylent+

Re: Google+ gets a redesign

#28
post #20
post #16

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Part of me wants this, too. But the other part of me hates it when a majority of my Facebook timeline is just updates from apps, games, and other crap that get automatically shared. This is a delicate balance.

On G+, you only see your friends' game update crap when you're on the Games tab.

True. But while I'd like to see some third-party auto-updates, I don't want to see all of them. This is the balance that needs to be struck.

Re: Google+ gets a redesign

#29
post #15
post #9

Yeah I really like this, and I also like how google is not giving up. I do think it has potential, and if google can hit it, it will be huge for the company. I think the piece that's missing is integration from other third party services - I would use my google+ account a lot more if I could post to it from apps I use often like twitter, instagram etc. There's always share to twitter in almost every app, which makes…

[deleted]

I downvoted you for using the word "ghey" as some sort of perjorative, but the rest of what you're saying isn't doing much to dissuade me from my assessment. (Edit - the OP has edited to remove the word "ghey" since my comment, it was originally right before the phrase "blog posts" as an adjective.)

IBM didn't lose out to an "operating system," if anything, it was Microsoft that made them capable of competing in the personal computer space.

Google+ is not having trouble gaining traction because they don't have enough features.

I get that you're trying to make a salient point about not underestimating new products, but it's not really cohesive. The fact that Microsoft and Google have succeeded with products in the past doesn't lead automatically to the conclusion that G+ is going to succeed.

Google+ could be a success, or it could wither and die. For any positive example you cite, you could equally cite things like Microsoft BOB, the Zune, Apple Newton, OS/2, WebOS, Maemo, Sega Dreamcast, etc.

There's far more to success than buckets of cash, innovation for the sake of innovation, or yard-long feature lists. I hope G+ continues to improve, but its success is not a foregone conclusion.

Re: Google+ gets a redesign

#30
post #4

I genuinely think Google+ has plenty of potential. Google's strategy seems a little more unified in terms of the way the posts are linking to search results, how you can setup circles and the other more niftier features that have been added that Facebook has yet to add. But despite all of that. Something is missing, and i just cant quite put my finger on it.

It's missing community integrations / anchors, though they will come with time.
Post reply on HN