Live data from Hacker News

Turmeric can kill cancer cells and prevent their growth

cancerresearchuk.org

21–28 of 28 posts

Re: Turmeric can kill cancer cells and prevent their growth

#21

It's been highly recommended in Hindu Ayurveda for centuries https://facebook.com/reel/306498222161882/

This seems like a meaningless data point. Avoiding pork and shellfish has been highly recommended in Jewish writing for millennia.

Sometimes for good reasons (e.g. food spoilage and parasites) that have no basis in 21st century reality.

Re: Turmeric can kill cancer cells and prevent their growth

#24

It's been highly recommended in Hindu Ayurveda for centuries https://facebook.com/reel/306498222161882/

This seems like a meaningless data point. Avoiding pork and shellfish has been highly recommended in Jewish writing for millennia. Sometimes for good reasons (e.g. food spoilage and parasites) that have no basis in 21st century reality.

Its not meaningless because the Ayurvedic scriptures are much older and the original scriptures that mention it first.

This is very important to note and to try and understand why it is so.

The use of turmeric dates back nearly 4000 years to the Vedic culture in India, where it was used as a culinary spice and had some religious significance. It probably reached China by 700 ad, East Africa by 800 ad, West Africa by 1200 ad, and Jamaica in the eighteenth century.

Re: Turmeric can kill cancer cells and prevent their growth

#25

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This seems like a meaningless data point. Avoiding pork and shellfish has been highly recommended in Jewish writing for millennia. Sometimes for good reasons (e.g. food spoilage and parasites) that have no basis in 21st century reality.

Its not meaningless because the Ayurvedic scriptures are much older and the original scriptures that mention it first. This is very important to note and to try and understand why it is so. The use of turmeric dates back nearly 4000 years to the Vedic culture in India, where it was used as a culinary spice and had some religious significance. It probably reached China by 700 ad, East Africa by 800 ad, West Africa by…

2000 years, 4000 years… humans make up things and as long as they’re not visibly and instantly harmful they persist.

If it turns out matzah ball soup prevents Alzheimer’s then millions of Jewish mothers will say “see! Our people knew it all along”, but it would be pure coincidence.

Re: Turmeric can kill cancer cells and prevent their growth

#26

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Its not meaningless because the Ayurvedic scriptures are much older and the original scriptures that mention it first. This is very important to note and to try and understand why it is so. The use of turmeric dates back nearly 4000 years to the Vedic culture in India, where it was used as a culinary spice and had some religious significance. It probably reached China by 700 ad, East Africa by 800 ad, West Africa by…

2000 years, 4000 years… humans make up things and as long as they’re not visibly and instantly harmful they persist. If it turns out matzah ball soup prevents Alzheimer’s then millions of Jewish mothers will say “see! Our people knew it all along”, but it would be pure coincidence.

It's not coincidence if there is science behind it and proven to be dated to vedic times. This is really important as there could be other things in the scriptures that are worth noting. Any good researcher wouldn't wash that off.

Re: Turmeric can kill cancer cells and prevent their growth

#28
post #3

Funny this was the other discussion it being contaminated. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38139011 Wikipedia suggests its toxify is overblown. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lead(II)_chromate >Despite containing both lead and hexavalent chromium, lead chromate is not particularly toxic because of its very low solubility. The LD50 for rats is only 5,000 mg/kg. Lead chromate is treated with great care in its manuf…

Because it has low solubility it will be less toxic compared to a more soluble form of lead, but it is still highly toxic and there is no safe dose. It has been implicated in numerous documented cases of lead poisoning from adulterated turmeric and you wouldn't want to be consuming it.
Post reply on HN