Live data from Hacker News

MyQ's horrible take on open access to their devices

memos.daviesgeek.com

21–23 of 23 posts

Re: MyQ's horrible take on open access to their devices

#21

Firstly, I completely agree with the sentiment in this post. I’m one of the many affected by this, and it’s annoying. Secondly, I have a hunch that there is a lawyer on the MyQ side that said that allowing customers to control their doors via api will open MyQ to liability. It’s an absurd argument since, well, it is a door with a remote control, but I can easily picture someone making that argument. I wish there was…

I run a similar API program for an IoT Manufacturer. Our API is public. I have a lot of thoughts about this. Supporting things like this is a mixed bag IMO. This group (especially Home Assistant) are very technical, hands on, and engaged. I'm a one man team (soon to be two). Between the "big guys" Alexa, Google, SmartThings, HomeKit, Paying Customers (RMR) it's hard to dedicate time to support what in my world are en…

Why require an API in the cloud? Wouldn't that simplify and reduce the exposure to the business?

Why not allow people to securely talk to the IOT device right on the local network? I think that then really puts a bright line on where the liability lays.

Re: MyQ's horrible take on open access to their devices

#23

Firstly, I completely agree with the sentiment in this post. I’m one of the many affected by this, and it’s annoying. Secondly, I have a hunch that there is a lawyer on the MyQ side that said that allowing customers to control their doors via api will open MyQ to liability. It’s an absurd argument since, well, it is a door with a remote control, but I can easily picture someone making that argument. I wish there was…

I run a similar API program for an IoT Manufacturer. Our API is public. I have a lot of thoughts about this. Supporting things like this is a mixed bag IMO. This group (especially Home Assistant) are very technical, hands on, and engaged. I'm a one man team (soon to be two). Between the "big guys" Alexa, Google, SmartThings, HomeKit, Paying Customers (RMR) it's hard to dedicate time to support what in my world are en…

TBH, I've always felt that the HA integration with myq was likely a burden for them. It makes way too many requests, IIRC.

But that isn't really their reason. They don't allow IFTT to open the door. Alexa and Google Assistant support is extremely limited.

They've focused on partnerships that directly produce revenue. It is purely a cash grab.

Post reply on HN