Live data from Hacker News

OpenTF is now OpenTofu

github.com

21–30 of 260 posts

Re: OpenTF is now OpenTofu

#21
post #6

Kind of makes sense, it made OpenTF made me think of OpenTheFuck ... which is not ideal.

I was seriously expecting some sort of open sourced tools for making tofu. As a vegetarian that likes to cook I was a little disappointed, but this sounds good as well.

Re: OpenTF is now OpenTofu

#22
post #11

At the time of posting, this submission links directly to the OpenTofu Github organization, which does not say anything about the name change. Here are some links that are specifically about the name change: - https://github.com/opentofu/opentofu/issues/296 - https://techcrunch.com/2023/09/20/terraform-fork-gets-a-new-... - https://www.theregister.com/2023/09/20/terraform_fork_opentf...

From the last link: " The name OpenTofu was adopted out of concern for, as you might have already guessed, trademark litigation. " Because Hashicorp might not like the "TF" (for Terraform).

Out of curiosity, how does OpenJDK not get sued into fine pulp over this? Oracle owns the Java trademark and aren’t exactly known for being kind in matters of litigation.

Re: OpenTF is now OpenTofu

#24

Hey! Interim tech lead of OpenTofu here. I'd like to add that as of today (announced just now at OSS Bilbao) we're officially part of the Linux Foundation[0]! Hope you like the new name (it basically won the votes anywhere it was proposed) and happy to answer any questions! [0]: https://www.linuxfoundation.org/press/announcing-opentofu

Have you considered terrafork?

Sure. But names including “terra” would be even more risky. Someone suggested LunarSpoon though and I personally found it hilarious.

Re: OpenTF is now OpenTofu

#25
post #22
post #11

Earlier quoted context omitted.

From the last link: " The name OpenTofu was adopted out of concern for, as you might have already guessed, trademark litigation. " Because Hashicorp might not like the "TF" (for Terraform).

Out of curiosity, how does OpenJDK not get sued into fine pulp over this? Oracle owns the Java trademark and aren’t exactly known for being kind in matters of litigation.

OpenJDK is also trademarked by Oracle[0], they're not gonna sue themselves.

[0] https://openjdk.org/legal/openjdk-trademark-notice.html

Re: OpenTF is now OpenTofu

#26
post #22
post #11

Earlier quoted context omitted.

From the last link: " The name OpenTofu was adopted out of concern for, as you might have already guessed, trademark litigation. " Because Hashicorp might not like the "TF" (for Terraform).

Out of curiosity, how does OpenJDK not get sued into fine pulp over this? Oracle owns the Java trademark and aren’t exactly known for being kind in matters of litigation.

OpenJDK is now the open-part of the JDK which multiple groups provide builds and customizations for.

What I think you are talking about when you say OpenJDK is called Adoptium now (https://adoptopenjdk.net/releases.html). Earlier called Adopt OpenJDK.

Similarly Eclipse folks named their project Temurin and so on.

Re: OpenTF is now OpenTofu

#27

Hey! Interim tech lead of OpenTofu here. I'd like to add that as of today (announced just now at OSS Bilbao) we're officially part of the Linux Foundation[0]! Hope you like the new name (it basically won the votes anywhere it was proposed) and happy to answer any questions! [0]: https://www.linuxfoundation.org/press/announcing-opentofu

Will the CLI be renamed to `tofu`?

Re: OpenTF is now OpenTofu

#28
post #27

Hey! Interim tech lead of OpenTofu here. I'd like to add that as of today (announced just now at OSS Bilbao) we're officially part of the Linux Foundation[0]! Hope you like the new name (it basically won the votes anywhere it was proposed) and happy to answer any questions! [0]: https://www.linuxfoundation.org/press/announcing-opentofu

Will the CLI be renamed to `tofu`?

Yep!

Re: OpenTF is now OpenTofu

#29
The new branding is recognizable, cute and short. However, Tofu has a somewhat mixed reputation. I guess OpenTofu can stand on its own though.
Post reply on HN