Live data from Hacker News

London Street Trees

apps.london.gov.uk

21–30 of 74 posts

Re: London Street Trees

#21
post #18

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Interesting these maps are missing many trees such as the DC missing those around the the capital building. Presumably because different organizations are in charge of them.

When it's the building, the correct spelling is capitol.

Interesting, I’ve seen both used so often I just assumed either worked.

Re: London Street Trees

#23
Huh, looks like Montreal has one of these as well... never would have known.

https://quebio.ca/en/arbresmtl

EDIT: Wondering about the distinct areas without trees on the island? Those are buroughs that look as though they don't report to the City of Montreal. In the case of Westmount, it's because they are a distinct city.

Re: London Street Trees

#24
post #18
post #5

This is an unusually nice website, but if you like this, check your own city, they might have one too! For example, here's: DC: https://trees.dc.gov/apps/3677bceead544db79a412e3ab0a68588/e... Boston: https://boston.maps.arcgis.com/apps/webappviewer/index.html?... LA: https://losangelesca.treekeepersoftware.com/index.cfm

Interesting these maps are missing many trees such as the DC missing those around the the capital building. Presumably because different organizations are in charge of them.

Yes there is a different map for DC parks: https://caseytrees.maps.arcgis.com/apps/webappviewer/index.h..., but it also doesn't have the ones right around the Capitol. I would guess that's because it is federal and not handled by the city? The White House is also not covered, but the Ellipse and the Mall right below it is.

Re: London Street Trees

#27
post #8

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Tbh I feel like that's probably an underestimate, but otoh that's probably a fraction of the cost of maintaining the trees themselves, so I'm not sure it's worth fretting over.

And the whole point of having a government of London is because it's a huge city. If it was just a large car park it wouldn't need a government. The city is for people, and people both like trees and benefit from many properties of these trees such as their ability to absorb rainfall and provide shade as well as positive contribution to air quality (well, unless you're allergic to tree pollen) so it makes sense for t…

I don't think any comment is being made on the utility or not of the trees.

I think the comment is specifically about the custom built website to track and map the trees.

Re: London Street Trees

#29
post #13

I bet this this website cost London £100k or more. They probably contracted it out to some supplier to build and maintain, and they are charging through the nose for hosting it, because the people on the London horticultural team don't do HTML. While I applaud the effort, I do wonder if it is tax money well spent. Perhaps a spreadsheet on a shared drive would have been better value for money?

London GDP is about £500 billion. They’ll need this info to maintain the trees in any case. If it cost 100k, it would be 0.02% of GDP. For the difference trees make to urban areas, it would be utterly trivial. If you made £50k cash after tax a year (so closer to 80k before tax), it would be £10 a year, that’s the fraction. Of course it costs far more than £100k to maintain this data.

I think most Londoners wouldn't want to pay £10/year for a tree database.

Imagine a sign saying "Just donate £10 so we can have a database to tell us where our trees are", I bet the vast majority of Londoners wouldn't hand over £10.

Even a keen gardener wouldn't likely pay £10 to have a map of where all the vegetables in their vegetable patch were.

Re: London Street Trees

#30
post #28

i should point out that not all of the uk cares as much for its trees: https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2023/mar/06/sheffield-ci...

This is specifically the council. Local resident care an awful lot about their trees and there are many local campaigns to make sure something like that doesn’t happen again. I think the local labour party ended up replacing some of the MP’s involved. (I live in Sheffield)
Post reply on HN