Live data from Hacker News

Does history have a replication crisis?

ageofinvention.xyz

21–22 of 22 posts

Re: Does history have a replication crisis?

#21
post #20
post #8

In order to become a history teacher, I had to get a master’s degree in education. I was required to take a minimum of five graduate-level history classes in the history department as part of it. I was transitioning from being a lawyer. Professors would talk about checking citations (although not systematically) but it was more for the purpose of finding useful material you want to use, not to check how they are bein…

> Suffice to say, I got the message And this is at least part of why I don't do well in academia (and, tbf, many other settings); I refuse to get the message.

I had a different objective: get my MAT (Master of Arts in Teaching), get certified in my state and get a job at a secondary school. They were threatening to throw a monkey-wrench at me. It wasn’t worth the trouble.

Had I been a history graduate student, on the other hand, I very well have fought that fight, because it represents a significant problem in the field of academic history.

Re: Does history have a replication crisis?

#22
post #8

In order to become a history teacher, I had to get a master’s degree in education. I was required to take a minimum of five graduate-level history classes in the history department as part of it. I was transitioning from being a lawyer. Professors would talk about checking citations (although not systematically) but it was more for the purpose of finding useful material you want to use, not to check how they are bein…

About five years ago I asked myself whether I wanted to pursue a career change out of tech. I’m always excited by history and I’m sad that more people don’t feel the same way. I considered becoming a history professor or teacher and it was the credentials required that stopped me.

I’ve never had the patience for school even though I love to learn. I make a good living in my field despite not having a CS degree like many of my peers. I commend you for taking it upon yourself to do what I did not. I hope you have a very successful teaching career, by which I mean that I hope you have at least one student discover the joy in learning history.

Post reply on HN