Live data from Hacker News

Ways to teach kids to code (2016)

medium.com

21–30 of 50 posts

Re: Ways to teach kids to code (2016)

#21
Is it still useful to teach kids how to code? I'm genuinely asking. I am the father of two 12-year-olds and I'm teaching them how to code, but I wonder if it will really be useful in the long run, in a world where there is ChatGPT, AI code assistants, and, most importantly, everything else that will emerge in the coming decade (i.e. english to code and whatnot)

Re: Ways to teach kids to code (2016)

#22
post #21

Is it still useful to teach kids how to code? I'm genuinely asking. I am the father of two 12-year-olds and I'm teaching them how to code, but I wonder if it will really be useful in the long run, in a world where there is ChatGPT, AI code assistants, and, most importantly, everything else that will emerge in the coming decade (i.e. english to code and whatnot)

Well all of those things already exist. What kind of things are your 12 year ilds able to do with them? Could they work as a software engineer now?

Re: Ways to teach kids to code (2016)

#23
post #21

Is it still useful to teach kids how to code? I'm genuinely asking. I am the father of two 12-year-olds and I'm teaching them how to code, but I wonder if it will really be useful in the long run, in a world where there is ChatGPT, AI code assistants, and, most importantly, everything else that will emerge in the coming decade (i.e. english to code and whatnot)

Is it useful to teach kids adding numbers? Computers can do it millions of times faster/larger numbers for decades.

Re: Ways to teach kids to code (2016)

#24

Earlier quoted context omitted.

There are many different paths to the same goal. Some kids are maybe better off just picking up C documentation and going straight for it. Some are better starting with some web based gamified psuedo language.

No. If you have to infantilize something for them, they're not capable of learning it.

Kids learn to read with children's books, not by reading Ulysses

Re: Ways to teach kids to code (2016)

#25
post #21

Is it still useful to teach kids how to code? I'm genuinely asking. I am the father of two 12-year-olds and I'm teaching them how to code, but I wonder if it will really be useful in the long run, in a world where there is ChatGPT, AI code assistants, and, most importantly, everything else that will emerge in the coming decade (i.e. english to code and whatnot)

Coding is the 21st century version of what literacy was in the 19th century.

Not everyone back then knew how to read and write, but enough people did to substantially change society. If you could read and write there was work that only you could do in the new economy. At the same time, being literate did not mean you were the new Shakespeare, you were probably using it for something mundane like sending letters on behalf of a business.

Likewise with coding. There will be loads of jobs that only a code literate person can do. It's also quite possible that you don't write any large or important piece of software, your whole life's work might be a bunch of python scripts that glue together other people's contributions.

Knowing how to code is also similar to literacy in another sense. The literate will be the first people to access new ideas. Want to read Das Kapital? Gotta know how to read. Want to know how an AI assistant works? Gotta know how to code.

Re: Ways to teach kids to code (2016)

#26

We don't need to make everything kid friendly. There were no fun algebra games, you just did the work. You didn't even understand why the work was useful, you just had to do it. When kids have the mental faculties advanced enough to learn computer programming, you teach them just like you teach algebra.

Seeing my kid what he does/knows about numbers after watching numberblocks and playing with printouts of those little guys he’s asking for - before knowing how to read - I can’t disagree more.

The best secret of life is that you need to fall in love with practicing what you want to achieve.

There is no better way than through play.

Re: Ways to teach kids to code (2016)

#27
post #21

Is it still useful to teach kids how to code? I'm genuinely asking. I am the father of two 12-year-olds and I'm teaching them how to code, but I wonder if it will really be useful in the long run, in a world where there is ChatGPT, AI code assistants, and, most importantly, everything else that will emerge in the coming decade (i.e. english to code and whatnot)

That's a strange way to frame it. Every skill is useful in some context. As a parent, I think a more productive way to think about it is to ask whether teaching kids anything is in line with your values. For me, I'd prefer if my kids were well rounded from being exposed to many different things, so they can make informed decisions later in life. That means they have lego mindstorms, but if they say they like tennis or they spend time drawing sidescroller games and not twirling to nutcracker ballet videos, then so be it. For some parents, laser focusing on something might be considered preferable.

Re: Ways to teach kids to code (2016)

#29
post #24

Earlier quoted context omitted.

No. If you have to infantilize something for them, they're not capable of learning it.

Kids learn to read with children's books, not by reading Ulysses

That's an age appropriate activity. They don't make a children's calculus book.
Post reply on HN