Live data from Hacker News

Target's EasySweep – Simplifying Skimmer Detection

tech.target.com

21–30 of 151 posts

Re: Target's EasySweep – Simplifying Skimmer Detection

#21

Did I read this wrong? They are using the card chip slot to house the skimmer protection, so chip and pin will not work ?

It's not "protection" but a testing tool. If the tool fits as expected then there probably isn't a skimmer. Then you remove the tool

Re: Target's EasySweep – Simplifying Skimmer Detection

#24
Since it's only implied how it works and there seems to be some confusion in the comments. It seems like the technique is to simply create a very form-fitting insert which won't fit properly if some device is overlaid onto the machine. The insert is not left in the device, but is just used for a quick in-and-out check.

Re: Target's EasySweep – Simplifying Skimmer Detection

#25
post #4

it allows any Target team member to easily sweep a store for skimmers I'm unclear on how this is supposed to help - unless the skimmers are being installed by frickin ninjas it seems like they already needed insider cooperation.

If the target employee cannot see the skimmer detection tool, the terminal has been compromised. Most skimmers fit on top of the terminal which would obstruct sight of this tool/layer. There are videos online of these skimmers being "installed" and it takes about 1 to 2 seconds of work and it seems anyone can do it.

This tool is not permanently installed. It is a daily check for skimmers

Re: Target's EasySweep – Simplifying Skimmer Detection

#26

Did I read this wrong? They are using the card chip slot to house the skimmer protection, so chip and pin will not work ?

You read it wrong. It's not permanently attached. They stick a very precise 3D object in the chip slot, and if it doesn't fit, that means the slot isn't the exact same as how the reader was made from the manufacturer. So you get a cashier to do that at the start of their shift, and if anything is detected they call out a more trained repair man/security professional to figure out if there is a skimmer.

Re: Target's EasySweep – Simplifying Skimmer Detection

#28
post #16

How do these skimmers work with chip&pin? I understand how magstripe skimmers work, but my understanding is that chip&pin is an active challenge response protocol. I’d love to hear more.

Even with EMV transactions, they are apparently able to get the card # which is transmitted in clear text by the chip. And the PIN from the keyboard overlay for debit transactions. Later they can clone the card # onto a fake mag stripe card and use the fake card for card-present purchases. They probably cannot make card-not-present (online) purchases since I don't think they can get the CVV. https://krebsonsecurity.c…

They might not need CVV, if the transaction looks “good” otherwise:

> A payment can still be successful even if the CVC or postal code check fails. This is because card issuers take many signals into account when making a decision about whether to approve or decline a payment. In some cases, a card issuer may still approve a payment they consider legitimate, even if the CVC or postal code verification check fails.

source: https://stripe.com/docs/radar/rules#built-in-rules

Re: Target's EasySweep – Simplifying Skimmer Detection

#29
post #26

Did I read this wrong? They are using the card chip slot to house the skimmer protection, so chip and pin will not work ?

You read it wrong. It's not permanently attached. They stick a very precise 3D object in the chip slot, and if it doesn't fit, that means the slot isn't the exact same as how the reader was made from the manufacturer. So you get a cashier to do that at the start of their shift, and if anything is detected they call out a more trained repair man/security professional to figure out if there is a skimmer.

So the skimmer asshole pays some Target employee $100 to replace the very precise 3d object with one that hides the skimmer when no one's looking?

I need a solution that lets me, the card holder, check these. This ain't it.

Hell, some of the internal skimmers just solder jumper wires to pcb pins/testpoints don't they? There's nothing mechanical for a card to touch. Target's got so many telescreen cameras in the store, they could likely get the pin numbers straight from that, no need to intercept that.

Post reply on HN