Live data from Hacker News

Sorry Mont Blanc, I will not be purchasing any product from you in the future

twitter.com

21–30 of 46 posts

Re: Sorry Mont Blanc, I will not be purchasing any product from you in the future

#21
I feel your frustration.

After the shenanigans I have experienced with my 2017 MacBook Pro (screen connector failure not warrantied on the 15”, premature battery failure, and obvs the butterfly keyboard) I’ve resolved to never buy another Apple laptop.

Assuming the 16” Framework stacks up, that’s where my money will go - I like (very much) all that they’re trying to do.

Re: Sorry Mont Blanc, I will not be purchasing any product from you in the future

#22

My wife and I absolutely love Monte Blanc, for their Fountain pens, Inks, leather and luxury goods. They are wonderful products and add a great deal to both our lives. That being said, I would never, ever, buy electronics from them. They simply aren't an electronics company. You wouldn't buy a fountain pen or leather bag from Sony and expect it to be a premium product would you?

I’d expect it to be mediocre quality, not an outright scam. Legitimate businesses don’t randomly decide to run a scam, so the fact that Mont Blanc did it here makes me strongly suspect we’re just not seeing how they do it elsewhere. Maybe you like their products, but are you familiar enough with the competition to know that you shouldn’t be getting more or paying less?

Re: Sorry Mont Blanc, I will not be purchasing any product from you in the future

#24
post #7

The only watch brand I buy is Casio, nothing smart, nothing for show off, it’s reliable, cheap, and certainly you can change its battery:)

If you go with solar you don't even need to do that. +1 for Casio

Re: Sorry Mont Blanc, I will not be purchasing any product from you in the future

#25

My wife and I absolutely love Monte Blanc, for their Fountain pens, Inks, leather and luxury goods. They are wonderful products and add a great deal to both our lives. That being said, I would never, ever, buy electronics from them. They simply aren't an electronics company. You wouldn't buy a fountain pen or leather bag from Sony and expect it to be a premium product would you?

>and add a great deal to both our lives

I never thought that someone will consider that fountain pens and luxury leather goods add a great deal in his life.

Re: Sorry Mont Blanc, I will not be purchasing any product from you in the future

#27

My wife and I absolutely love Monte Blanc, for their Fountain pens, Inks, leather and luxury goods. They are wonderful products and add a great deal to both our lives. That being said, I would never, ever, buy electronics from them. They simply aren't an electronics company. You wouldn't buy a fountain pen or leather bag from Sony and expect it to be a premium product would you?

>and add a great deal to both our lives I never thought that someone will consider that fountain pens and luxury leather goods add a great deal in his life.

My wife is a calligrapher. To a calligrapher or artist is like a baton is to a conductor, a Stradivarius to a violin player, a classic Gibson to a guitar player.

So yes, to many people an expensive guitar is just a status symbol, to a true artist it's something that adds a great deal to their lives.

It's the same here, my wife and I aren't lawyers, doctors or politicians, these pens aren't status symbols. These pens are used for creative pursuits, to design, art. Many of them are vintage classic pens that have deep history, family value, etc.

Just because you value certain things in your life, doesn't mean that others don't value other things.

Re: Sorry Mont Blanc, I will not be purchasing any product from you in the future

#28

My wife and I absolutely love Monte Blanc, for their Fountain pens, Inks, leather and luxury goods. They are wonderful products and add a great deal to both our lives. That being said, I would never, ever, buy electronics from them. They simply aren't an electronics company. You wouldn't buy a fountain pen or leather bag from Sony and expect it to be a premium product would you?

I’d expect it to be mediocre quality, not an outright scam. Legitimate businesses don’t randomly decide to run a scam, so the fact that Mont Blanc did it here makes me strongly suspect we’re just not seeing how they do it elsewhere. Maybe you like their products, but are you familiar enough with the competition to know that you shouldn’t be getting more or paying less?

Absolutely do. My wife and I regularly attend pen shows, own many different brands of pens not just monte blanc pens, in fact monte blanc are the minority in our collection.

In the fountain pen world Monte Blanc is like Rolex or Tag is to the watch world. One od the foundational brands of the genre.

Re: Sorry Mont Blanc, I will not be purchasing any product from you in the future

#29
This will sound silly but I don't understand the appeal of expensive watches. I can understand collecting or being interested in unique ones... but to an untrained eye (me) its hard to tell the difference between expensive and "fancy" ones.

At least with cars, you know when one is a sports car or expensive lol

Re: Sorry Mont Blanc, I will not be purchasing any product from you in the future

#30
post #29

This will sound silly but I don't understand the appeal of expensive watches. I can understand collecting or being interested in unique ones... but to an untrained eye (me) its hard to tell the difference between expensive and "fancy" ones. At least with cars, you know when one is a sports car or expensive lol

They're status symbols. As with most things in life, the quality isn't necessarily reflected by the price. "A fool and their money" et cetera. Cash circulating is a good thing, and provides jobs, even if the products they make are objectively not any better than x.
Post reply on HN