Live data from Hacker News

eBay’s Fast Billion-Scale Vector Similarity Engine

tech.ebayinc.com

21–26 of 26 posts

Re: eBay’s Fast Billion-Scale Vector Similarity Engine

#21

Good to see another engine leverage ScANN outside of Google. HNSW uses lots of RAM and it’s interesting how all the major engines settled on that algo. I’m interested in how they apply filtering, since with codebook based similarity such as PQ and ScANN it’s not trivial. Maybe one day we’ll also see someone implement a production ready Vamana engine too, which also does really well at the billion scale.

Agreed. There's a lot of great index types out there - HNSW is incredible, but algorithms such as ScANN (and PQ) have their place in the ecosystem.

Tree-based vector indexes aren't bad either, especially if we can find a way to make the random projections more efficient.

Re: eBay’s Fast Billion-Scale Vector Similarity Engine

#22
post #3

HNSW seems better in the criteria that matter. I think similarity search is a commodity now; I would not invest in developing an in-house solution given the abundance of good commercial solutions.

We've seen Milvus used in a variety of recommender systems running in production.

Re: eBay’s Fast Billion-Scale Vector Similarity Engine

#23
post #3

HNSW seems better in the criteria that matter. I think similarity search is a commodity now; I would not invest in developing an in-house solution given the abundance of good commercial solutions.

That depends a bit on the scale and use case specifics. But commoditized billion-scale vector search is indeed a thing. We published this for Weaviate in December last year https://weaviate.io/blog/sphere-dataset-in-weaviate

Re: eBay’s Fast Billion-Scale Vector Similarity Engine

#24
post #3

HNSW seems better in the criteria that matter. I think similarity search is a commodity now; I would not invest in developing an in-house solution given the abundance of good commercial solutions.

Such as...?

Vespa.ai is pretty crazy too, a bit unkown we run a huge vespa cluster serving 1k+ queries with <100ms latency ...

Re: eBay’s Fast Billion-Scale Vector Similarity Engine

#26
post #3

HNSW seems better in the criteria that matter. I think similarity search is a commodity now; I would not invest in developing an in-house solution given the abundance of good commercial solutions.

Such as...?

Typesense: https://typesense.org/docs/0.24.1/api/vector-search.html
Post reply on HN