Live data from Hacker News

Udacity and the future of online universities

blogs.reuters.com

21–30 of 73 posts

Re: Udacity and the future of online universities

#22
post #21

The actual website is here: http://www.udacity.com/ For those interested, looks like they're offering two classes (CS101: Building a Search Engine and CS373: Programming a Robotic Car) starting in February and hiring actively, as well ( http://www.udacity.com/jobs ).

Anyone else having issues signing up to the classes?

Re: Udacity and the future of online universities

#23

Part of the backstory here is that ai-class.com is by Udacity (Sebastian Thrun), while ml-class.org and pgm-class.org are by Coursera (Andrew Ng and Daphne Koller). Formerly colleagues from the same department, now competitors with very similar education startups, all the way down to the naming conventions. Lot of fur flying about who copied who. Coursera has been launching a ton of classes[1]. Probably Sebastian fee…

So, does this explain the unexpected delay of the Spring ML-Class? I haven't heard any news until a few days ago when I got an email saying there were delays in starting the new semester.

Re: Udacity and the future of online universities

#24
Since doing the online AI course, I have been hoping Thrun would teach Robotics.

I have signed up - woohoo. It looks awesome - I am stoked - Sebastian Thrun is an amazing teacher, he really makes me think hard and gives me the scaffolding to investigate further on my own.

Re: Udacity and the future of online universities

#25
post #21

The actual website is here: http://www.udacity.com/ For those interested, looks like they're offering two classes (CS101: Building a Search Engine and CS373: Programming a Robotic Car) starting in February and hiring actively, as well ( http://www.udacity.com/jobs ).

Anyone else having issues signing up to the classes?

I managed to sign up. (browser Chrome)

Re: Udacity and the future of online universities

#26
post #21

The actual website is here: http://www.udacity.com/ For those interested, looks like they're offering two classes (CS101: Building a Search Engine and CS373: Programming a Robotic Car) starting in February and hiring actively, as well ( http://www.udacity.com/jobs ).

Anyone else having issues signing up to the classes?

Me. It does nothing when I click on Enroll button.

Re: Udacity and the future of online universities

#27

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Could you please elaborate on how you reached such an interesting reasoning behind the launch of these classes.

I can confirm that his reasoning is correct. The word on the street is that Sebastian alienated the powers-that-be at Stanford.

That's too bad...for Stanford. It must have been a somewhat serious fight.

Re: Udacity and the future of online universities

#28

Part of the backstory here is that ai-class.com is by Udacity (Sebastian Thrun), while ml-class.org and pgm-class.org are by Coursera (Andrew Ng and Daphne Koller). Formerly colleagues from the same department, now competitors with very similar education startups, all the way down to the naming conventions. Lot of fur flying about who copied who. Coursera has been launching a ton of classes[1]. Probably Sebastian fee…

So, does this explain the unexpected delay of the Spring ML-Class? I haven't heard any news until a few days ago when I got an email saying there were delays in starting the new semester.

I'm interested in this question too. Two of my classes both sent the same type of email. I'd be very surprised if these aren't related.

Re: Udacity and the future of online universities

#29

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Could you please elaborate on how you reached such an interesting reasoning behind the launch of these classes.

I can confirm that his reasoning is correct. The word on the street is that Sebastian alienated the powers-that-be at Stanford.

How did this happen - did he want to push online education in different directions? Did he want to pursue more overtly commercial interests than his counterparts, which seem to be approaching it from a nonprofit sense? Was there a personal falling out between Andrew Ng and Sebastian Thrun?

The non-profit focused alternative seems to currently have both a better platform and more participation. Can a lesser amount of potential revenue allow this to scale up? Or will professor's be drawn by the larger salaries commercial teaching organizations could command, coupled with more extensive and rapid feature deployment?

Re: Udacity and the future of online universities

#30

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Could you please elaborate on how you reached such an interesting reasoning behind the launch of these classes.

I can confirm that his reasoning is correct. The word on the street is that Sebastian alienated the powers-that-be at Stanford.

I know of at least one Stanford student who feels swindled by this transition to online classes. 1. For some stanford costs a lot of money while online it's free and 2. The time taken developing this class may take away from the in person experience, further reducing the value of attending classes at Stanford.

Any idea if these feelings are wide spread? I only have the one sample.

Post reply on HN