Live data from Hacker News

The ethics of reclining airplane seats

lesswrong.com

21–30 of 96 posts

Re: The ethics of reclining airplane seats

#21
post #5

I’m in camp if they give you the option you have to assume the person in front will fully recline. No point in getting mad over it. If you want or need more space just get the premium seats if it means that much to you.

I'm hearing that because I'm 6'6" I should either be able to pay for premium or just never fly. That's a good excuse to get out an in-laws wedding next summer - I'll run it by my wife.

Re: The ethics of reclining airplane seats

#23
The less wrong word would be etiquette, not ethics.

This is a problem airlines have created making the customer feel morally obligated to solve. Most of the time, people feel bad about doing so that they believe others should behave the same way they feel when that’s not remotely the reality we live in.

Re: The ethics of reclining airplane seats

#24
Lots of interesting arguments. I like the suggestion at the end that just politely asking before reclining is the simplest way to resolve this question.

There's an (understandable) tendency in rationalist circles to assume social conventions have little value but sometimes they reflect accumulated wisdom. Be a good neighbor and ask before you do something that affects people nearby, regardless of whether you have a unilateral right to do it.

Re: The ethics of reclining airplane seats

#26
On EasyJet, seats do not recline. I remember the first time I discovered this, thinking what a brilliant idea and why doesn't everyone do this?

Of course, it helps that their flights are mostly short-haul (mentioned in the article).

Re: The ethics of reclining airplane seats

#27

seems like the actual problem is the meager space provided in the first place, not the scraps of free room we're forced to battle over

Yet people continue to vote their purchasing dollars for too-tight seat spacing - because the cost of roomier seats is for-sure and up-front. Vs. hope springs eternal on the reality that you'll get.

Re: The ethics of reclining airplane seats

#29
Airplanes are such a bizarre space.

I’ve seen many people break rules or even the law just because they wanted to (failure to wear mask, trying to get their kid to sit in an exit aisle, drinking, drinking in the exit aisle). Some of the rules change flight to flight. Either people’s behavior changes in these spaces, or I should lower my expectations. Probably the latter.

Re: The ethics of reclining airplane seats

#30
I'm pretty small and so don't ever recline because I know how annoying it is. However, if I was exceptionally tall I probably would fully recline in order to just not be miserable. When someone fully reclines in front of me I'm really annoyed but don't hold a grudge. It's their seat to recline after all. Heh the whole scenario is like a little illustration of your beliefs and values.
Post reply on HN