Live data from Hacker News

Indian Air Force inducts natively developed light combat helicopter ‘Prachanda’

amritmahotsav.nic.in

21–30 of 174 posts

Re: Indian Air Force inducts natively developed light combat helicopter ‘Prachanda’

#21
Is there any point to helicopters anymore with the increasing capabilities of drones?

See Turkish drone use in UA/RU war. For a single helicopter, you could blanket the skies with drones. Now they aren't dirt cheap, $5 million, but that's a hellva lot cheaper than a single heli.

Re: Indian Air Force inducts natively developed light combat helicopter ‘Prachanda’

#22

Is there any point to helicopters anymore with the increasing capabilities of drones? See Turkish drone use in UA/RU war. For a single helicopter, you could blanket the skies with drones. Now they aren't dirt cheap, $5 million, but that's a hellva lot cheaper than a single heli.

Try fitting a squad, let alone a platoon, into one of those drones...

Re: Indian Air Force inducts natively developed light combat helicopter ‘Prachanda’

#23
Where do attack helicopters fit into modern war, out of curiosity? From my very uninformed point of view -- seems like in a world where man-portable weapons are getting more and more capable, being in a relatively (compared to jets) slowly moving, lightly (?) armored flying vehicle would be pretty terrifying.

Re: Indian Air Force inducts natively developed light combat helicopter ‘Prachanda’

#24
post #20
post #18

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Because they were told to at gunpoint? Obviously there should be a better reason than that. But hard leaning nationalists tend to lack better ideas.

All love is irrational. I would still rather love. Some people stay because they care, no need to be disparaging of them. You and I would not enjoy the peace and comfort of the modern world without it because somebody is irrationally willing to live/die for you and me.

There's nothing wrong with nationalism. But typically your sales pitch has to be your country is actually good, not we have to force you (and millions of others) to be here otherwise it won't be good.

Re: Indian Air Force inducts natively developed light combat helicopter ‘Prachanda’

#25

Where do attack helicopters fit into modern war, out of curiosity? From my very uninformed point of view -- seems like in a world where man-portable weapons are getting more and more capable, being in a relatively (compared to jets) slowly moving, lightly (?) armored flying vehicle would be pretty terrifying.

Attack helicopters are designed for anti-tank, and some anti-infantry and escort. Yes they’re vulnerable. You’re trading off that risk with being able to being able to move extremely quickly and long distance compared to the tanks they’re fighting.

If you want to be very safe you can sit static encased in a metre thick steel shell, but you won’t achieve anything.

Re: Indian Air Force inducts natively developed light combat helicopter ‘Prachanda’

#27

India could benefit greatly from restricting the emmigration of her top talented people. Right now the smartest Indians work abroad. The increasingly anti-west foreign policy might be early indications of steps towards that.

>The increasingly anti-west foreign policy might be early indications of steps towards that.

There is no 'anti-west' foreign policy. India follows neutrality in most geo-political nonsense due to its non-alignment philosophy. It has followed it for the past 75 years and will continue to follow it.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Non-Aligned_Movement

Re: Indian Air Force inducts natively developed light combat helicopter ‘Prachanda’

#28
post #24
post #20

Earlier quoted context omitted.

All love is irrational. I would still rather love. Some people stay because they care, no need to be disparaging of them. You and I would not enjoy the peace and comfort of the modern world without it because somebody is irrationally willing to live/die for you and me.

There's nothing wrong with nationalism. But typically your sales pitch has to be your country is actually good, not we have to force you (and millions of others) to be here otherwise it won't be good.

There can be a lot wrong with nationalism, depending on the definition. I love "us" can also be I hate "the others". And quickly become "the others must not exist". For some arbitrary distinction of what is "us" and what is "others".

Re: Indian Air Force inducts natively developed light combat helicopter ‘Prachanda’

#29
post #9
post #2

Made me dig around for more info: Attack Helicopters Fleet Strength by Country -- https://www.globalfirepower.com/aircraft-helicopters-attack.... Helicopter manufacturer countries -- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Helicopter_manufacturer

Wonder if those strength numbers are pre-war. The Ukrainians claim to have downed over 250 Ruzzian helicopers, half their fleet.

I believe that number is all helicopters, not specifically dedicated attack helicopters. So it would include things like transport copters.

That being said, 2 more ded Russian copters in the past 24 hours. Hurrah.

Re: Indian Air Force inducts natively developed light combat helicopter ‘Prachanda’

#30

Where do attack helicopters fit into modern war, out of curiosity? From my very uninformed point of view -- seems like in a world where man-portable weapons are getting more and more capable, being in a relatively (compared to jets) slowly moving, lightly (?) armored flying vehicle would be pretty terrifying.

I think we’re in a transition period where it looks like drones will probably replace scout and attack helicopters. In the mean time a chopper like this probably still has a role, but I think they’re on the wrong side of history with this.

For now though, while western militaries can afford to hand out LAWS and MANPADS to their troops like sweets, India’s main rivals probably can’t. Yes an individual MANPAD is much cheaper than a chopper, but to defend your entire army from a few dozen choppers you’ll need to hand out a heck of a lot of MANPADS to get the coverage.

The main saving grace of a system like this is that the munitions, unguided rockets and cannon rounds, are pretty cheap. In contrast while drones are much cheaper than the chopper, they’re very expensive as munitions.

Post reply on HN