Live data from Hacker News

I made outlines for KDE Breeze window decoration

akselmo.dev

21–30 of 114 posts

Re: I made outlines for KDE Breeze window decoration

#21

Quoted post unavailable.

KDE getting window borders, Gnome getting thumbnails in the file picker, what's going on? Next you're gonna tell me that Wayland will be usable in the next decade.

>Next you're gonna tell me that Wayland will be usable in the next decade.

It's already usable today, so I don't see why you'd need to wait for a decade.

Re: I made outlines for KDE Breeze window decoration

#22

> But what happens if shadows are disabled? > Something cheeky happens! I actually draw the shadows with 0% alpha channel! Does that still pay the performance cost to "draw" them, or does it get optimized away?

If you're using a compositor you're paying the cost. The rounded corners are antialiased, so blending happens regardless.

Re: I made outlines for KDE Breeze window decoration

#23
post #12
post #9

Earlier quoted context omitted.

KDE uses gpu acceleration for its ui. So that should be a negligible impact on performance. I am unsure about if you even have shadows with CPU rendering.

Using software rendering instead of OpenGL disables most if not all effects from what I remember.

iirc software rendering in kwin disables compositing alltogether

Re: I made outlines for KDE Breeze window decoration

#25

I haven't touched KDE in maybe 15 years. I just always defaulted to Gnome when I'm on Linux desktop. But this looks more macOS like. Just curious, is there any reason I should try KDE today?

If you like MacOS, you might be presently surprised with the direction KDE has been heading over the past few years. Many apps support a global menu (eg. Mac-like menu on arbitrary panels/docks), and the trackpad support with Wayland is almost 1:1 with MacOS (only missing Force Touch). I'm very happy with how things have been headed recently, and have been using it ever since GNOME 40 dropped.

Re: I made outlines for KDE Breeze window decoration

#27

I haven't touched KDE in maybe 15 years. I just always defaulted to Gnome when I'm on Linux desktop. But this looks more macOS like. Just curious, is there any reason I should try KDE today?

>is there any reason I should try KDE today The DE is a personal preference thing. It's nobody's job to convince you to try anything. It's up to you to decide to try it if you're curious. Since you haven't tried KDE in 15 years, you've probably missed a lot. There are also countless KDE Reviews online and on YouTube.

I went back to KDE after a lifetime using Gnome (and then Cinnamon when Gnome3 ruined things).

KDE has been a joy and is now my DE of choice.

Re: I made outlines for KDE Breeze window decoration

#28

Earlier quoted context omitted.

KDE getting window borders, Gnome getting thumbnails in the file picker, what's going on? Next you're gonna tell me that Wayland will be usable in the next decade.

>Next you're gonna tell me that Wayland will be usable in the next decade. It's already usable today, so I don't see why you'd need to wait for a decade.

>It's already usable today, so I don't see why you'd need to wait for a decade.

No, it's not usable for me.

I still can't share my screen in Slack or Teams making calls with Windows and Mac colleagues an embarrassing mess.

Firefox in Ubuntu 22.04 has Wayland disabled by default (why though, if Wayland is so usable?)

No scroll acceleration settings.

Currently, Wayland is one step forward, one step back. Especially that many highly used apps still haven't made the switch and that Wayland has not yet feature parity to what X11 offered.

Re: I made outlines for KDE Breeze window decoration

#29
post #18

I haven't touched KDE in maybe 15 years. I just always defaulted to Gnome when I'm on Linux desktop. But this looks more macOS like. Just curious, is there any reason I should try KDE today?

GNOME is being obsoleted by KDE.

Yeah right

Re: I made outlines for KDE Breeze window decoration

#30
post #20

I haven't touched KDE in maybe 15 years. I just always defaulted to Gnome when I'm on Linux desktop. But this looks more macOS like. Just curious, is there any reason I should try KDE today?

KDE dev here. From a developer perspective, something I really love with Plasma (the 'new' branding for KDE) is that it's really modular by design. Everything on the screen is pluggable with a very simple api and can theoricaly be be swapped out or experimented with. This includes the widgets but also the visual effects. For example, Marco (a prominent Plasma hacker) just worked on a new basic tilling extension and w…

> From an user point of view, I often try to not change too much default settings, but there are some really nice feature I enjoy. kde connect is particularly nice for the media player integration with my phone). Yakuake is a nice dropdown terminal. The wayland port is really smooth, there is a lot of features everywhere and I often make use of a big percentage.

The overwhelming majority of the people I know who use KDE also try to not change too much from the default settings, but the settings we change are all different.

It's similar with the bells and whistles in Plasma; I probably use a single-digit percentage of them, but they are probably different set from what other users use. I am grateful for those who maintain these features, because I'm sure both that developing would be easier with fewer features and there is probably nobody who uses all of them.

Post reply on HN